Re: Saying Where You Are #general


Nick <tulse04-news@...>
 

"Yehudh bn Shlmo" <ybs1207@yahoo.com> wrote
I have yet to hear a good reason why it is necessary
for anyone to give a location. And my person opinion,
is that it is just being snoopy. However, if you are
curious, ask. But please don't refuse to provide a
vital link about someone's family if they don't give a location.
After all, If a person said I am looking for an Obit for Jane
Doe >from 1966 in New York City, what significance does
the person's location have, other than providing what
time of day it is where they are?
If I knew that you lived in NY I might suggest that you visit New York City
Library whereas if you lived in Australia I would suggest differently.

There was a recent series of postings regarding the S55 form which I believe
relates to Social Security in the USA. I live in the UK but it was assumed
that everyone on the newsgroup would know what was being referred to.

Given that this is an international newsgroup/discussion group it makes a
lot of sense to know where they are posting from, so that potential posters
can make a judgement as to what information/sources/buildings the poster is
likely to have access to.

Of course, if the poster chooses not to reveal that information that is
clearly up to them (and the Moderators).

But I would add that every time someone makes a request for some information
about a relative or an ancestor, they are giving up something personal.

I can't see how this sort of discussion group can work without providing the
kind of information that the poster seems to object to revealing.

I am also concerned about my own personal privacy, but clearly by taking
part in this newsgroup I have given away a little of that.

After all, if I make a comment on someone else's posting regarding the
situation in the US, I would have thought that it was relevant that I live
in England, if nothing else.


--
Nick Landau
London, UK

COHNREICH (Anklam, Germany Krajenka, Poland) ATLAS (Wielkie Oczy (near
Lvov/Lemberg), Poland) WEITZMAN (Cracow), WECHSLER(Schwabach, Germany)
KOHN/WEISSKOPF (Wallerstein and Kleinerdlingen,Germany) LANDAU (only adopted
on leaving Belarus or later)/FREDKIN (?) (Gomel, Mogilev, Chernigov, Belarus)

Join main@groups.jewishgen.org to automatically receive all group messages.