Re: Why they left the Pale #general

Jules Levin

At 02:18 AM 7/16/2012, Aubrey Jacobus wrote:
Being the child of an immigrant I am always conscious of the fact that but
for my father's decision to leave Poland to avoid the Czar's army (where
all his brothers had served), I would certainly not be alive today.

My father always spoke nostalgically of his home shtetl and never spoke
of a fear of progroms although he was well aware of them occurring
elsewhere in the Pale.
Compare the actual numbers killed in pogroms before WW I with the total
Jewish population, and it is clear that most Jews did not live in dread of
their neighbors >from day to day. It might be interesting to compare those
numbers with the population of Chicago and the numbers of people killed
there by gang violence each year. I suspect the ratios would be embarrassing.

Also, I don't know the actual laws applicable, but in general a young man
whose brothers had served should have been exempt >from military service.
Economics was the main reason to leave; material conditions were bad in
the shtetlach, and the high Jewish birth rate was producing many young men
unable to find work.

Jules Levin
Los Angeles

Join to automatically receive all group messages.