German SIG #Germany Re: Medical advice -- and given name Falk #germany


Prof. G. L. Esterson <jerry@...>
 

MODERATOR NOTE: I believe that it is fair to conclude that the derivation of the
family name FALK is not positively known. In the future, GerSig members writing
about this matter will be directed to our archives where the names and email
addresses of the various sages who have opinions on the matter can be found.

The GerSig Forum is for sharing information of **immediate**
relevance to German-Jewish Genealogy research. As we have
suggested many times in the past, those GerSig members who wish
to debate unresolved questions regarding Jewish name derivation
at are invited to find or to form an email discussion group on that
topic.
***END of FALK debate here*** and END of approval for this list of messages from
Dr. Nussbaum and others which do not strictly adhere to our format standards.
End of MOD NOTE. John Paul Lowens MODERATOR=========>

Dan Nussbaum posted as follows:

"Most Jewish onamasticians disagree with Kaganoff about "Falk." They think it
is a diminutive for Raphael, not a kinui for Joshua." ======>

Hilchot Gitin (Jewish divorce law) books agree with Kaganoff that the
Yiddish name Falk and some of its variants were kinuim for the Hebrew given
names Yehoshua and Yoshua. For example, the book "Get Mesudar" which
applies to Ashkenaz regions for the 19th century state this. This means
that Jewish law mandates that the name Yehoshua haMechune Falk must be
written (in Hebrew characters) in a Get (Jewish divorce contract) to
identify the man if he had those two names.

It is possible that those onomasticians to whom Mr Nussbaum may be
referring mistook the name Falk for some of the known Yiddish nicknames
which WERE used in Germany for men who had the Hebrew name Refaeyl, e.g.,
Fael. The mistake could be made by identifying the Yiddish nickname Falek
(a variant of Falk) as being similar to the name Fael, when in fact it was
never (to my knowledge) used by Jews in conjunction with the Hebrew name
Refaeyl, but only Yehoshua.

These names are included in the Germany Given Names Data Base web site on
JewishGen at < www.jewishgen.org/databases/GivenNames/ > and illustrate the
above name relationships.

I believe that Kaganoff was correct.

Professor G. L. Esterson, Ra'anana, Israel <jerry@vms.huji.ac.il>

Join main@groups.jewishgen.org to automatically receive all group messages.