JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen mtDNA haplogroup I #general
Jane
Hello Everybody,
I am in mtDNA group I, and I'm confused by something. When I look at my matches on the Family Tree DNA website, the names look like a list of contributors to the UJA. And yet, Wikipedia says, "Haplogroup I is found at very low frequencies(generally <3%) throughout Europe, Middle East, and South Asia. It is nearly absent in parts of Europe (Iberia, Southwest France, Ireland) and strongest in Iceland(>5%), Scotland, Norway, southern Finland, Ukraine, Greece and western Anatolia. A February 2009 study found that Lemkos (a sup- or co-ethnic group of Rusyns) in the Carpathian Mountains have the "highest frequency of haplogroup I (11.3%) in Europe. . ." Jews in Iceland? Lemkos? They are Orthodox Christians. I just don't get it. At this point, there are about 75 matches in mtDNA group I. It looks like just about all of us are Jewish. The only thing I can think of that would explain this is the idea that perhaps Jews are more likely to research their ancestry and send in DNA samples than other ethnic groups. Anybody have any ideas? My mother's a Galitzianer, BTW. My maternal grandmother's mother's maiden name was Weintraub. Thanks, Jane Smith researching Weintraub, Jungermann, Rosenreich, Wallace, Zeman, Bogorad (or something like that) MODERATOR NOTE: Discussions regarding the results of DNA testing are beyond the scope of this more general Jewish Genealogy forum. However, JewishGen does have a forum geared to just this issue: "DNA Testing." We suggest you go to http://www.jewishgen.org/ListManager/members_add.asp Scroll down the page to find the DNA Testing Discussion Group subscription button. |
|