Rabbinic Genealogy SIG #Rabbinic Re: The TaZ #rabbinic
gregor brand <Gregor.Brand@...>
On 2002.10.22, Larry Tauber <Ltauber@ctswlaw.com> wrote:
4. I have never seen any review of Zuckerman's thesis regarding theI have read some decades ago several reviews of Prof. Zuckerman´s
book by noted historians in History journals. Although I don´t know
anymore, who the revievers were (I believe Prof. E. Hlawitschka was
one of them), I recall that they unanimously were very critical - to
say the least - about Zuckerman´s main findings and interpretations.
This does of course not necessarily mean that Zuckerman was wrong,
but it is probably not uninteresting to know that most historians in
this field don´t agree with Zuckerman about his arguments presented
in his "Jewish Princedom in Feudal France".
Gregor Brand, Bargstedt, Germany