Re: Percentages of ancestry - my Ashkenazi father seems to be partly of Italian/Greek descent? #dna
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
(I tried to use the links at the bottom to reply, but it opens
some email window that I am unfamiliar with.)
To everyone, please add dates to ggggrandparents, such as gggrandparent(b.1890),
otherwise there is no time reference for us to look at. Your gggrandparnet could
be my father's classmate.
Now to an answer. The DNA data does not give an absolute location but
a statistical probability location. When speaking of southeast Europe/N. Africa
and the Middle East, at the time between 1500-1900 the area was
mostly controlled by the Ottomans, and I expect many people,
especially military and political, traveled. Mistresses and one-night-stands are
not things invented in the last few years, but Thomas Jefferson and
DDE (to name just 2 POTUSs) were both well known to have mistresses.
When you start to read readin,
how do you know the fellow that
wrote the readin,
wrote the readin right?
Long Branch Saloon
Dodge City, Kansas
On Saturday, May 23, 2020, 05:53:45 PM GMT+3, <swerner@...> wrote:
I had my genes tested by FamilyTreeDNA. I already knew I had two very different lines of ancestry. My father's Ashkenazi Jewish (Belarus, Ukraine). My mother's of Irish and German descent. My results came back: Ashkenazi 38%, Ireland/British Isles 27%, West and Central Europe 23%, Southeast Europe 9%, East Europe < 3%.
The Southeast European bit was sort of a surprise. On my mother's side I know back to my great-great-great-grandparents in all cases and further back than that in some cases. (Of course, this assumes that everyone's father was the person their mother was married to.) On my father's side I only know back to my great-grandparents plus, in three out of four cases, their parents as well.
Is it possible that some of my father's ancestors came from Southeast Europe and later immigrated to the Pale to escape persecution? It's rather tantalizing that 38% + 9% + 3% adds up to 100%. (Of course, it could also be that some of that 23% West and Central Europe is coming from my father's side as well as my mother's. For example, my mother's Irish ancestry arises from three different women who immigrated from Ireland independently of each other, at different times and possibly from quite different parts of Ireland.)
I should also note that both my parents are now deceased. Each of them had one sibling, also now deceased. My father's sister had no children. So asking him or her or them to get their DNA tested isn't possible.
Many thanks for any info!
RABINOVICH: Chopovichi, Ukraine
GITELMAN: David-Gorodok, Belarus