Re: How to correct information in Jewishgen Databases #records
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
In 22 years of research, I have come across facts in vital records, censuses, etc.
that I know to be incorrect. You don't know if the person giving the information made the error or the person writing it on the record did so.
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
-------- Original message --------
From: Peter Cherna <peter@...>
Date: 8/28/20 10:10 PM (GMT-05:00)
Subject: Re: [JewishGen.org] How to correct information in Jewishgen Databases #records
I appreciate your conundrum, and understand your desire here. That said, if the JewishGen database entries match the source documents from which they are based (e.g. birth registers), but your original family documents do not match that, then whether you personally agree or not, no correction would be possible, nor would it be appropriate. There are extremely solid reasons for this that are widely held by professional archivists and others whose job it is to make historical records available.
I'm sorry you don't seem to agree, but such opinions do not really come into play for JewishGen or any other repository of historical records, whose primary job is to make accessible accurate copies of those records. (It might be interesting for JewishGen to allow tagging and commentary alongside individual entries, but that is a significant challenge to implement, and would be absolutely daunting to administer.)
The challenge and puzzle and delight of genealogy is to stitch some kind of "whole" from primary and other sources that don't always perfectly accord. If your goal is to have a public dataset that reflects your own reconciliation of those sources, then there are lots of places, including publishing your own tree on MyHeritage, or even on the JewishGen-hosted FamilyTree of the Jewish People. https://www.jewishgen.org/gedcom/ If your goal is to deem your reconciliation the one true representation of those families, then perhaps WikiTree or Geni is for you.
If your goal is to get the JewishGen databases to match your own valid documents while causing them to no longer match the documents upon with those databases are based, I can only encourage you to re-read all the responses to your original query, and work your way toward understanding why such a correction would, and should, be rejected.
Diane Jacobs, Somerset, New Jersey