JewishGen.org Discussion Group FAQs
What is the JewishGen.org Discussion Group?
The JewishGen.org Discussion Group unites thousands of Jewish genealogical researchers worldwide as they research their family history, search for relatives, and share information, ideas, methods, tips, techniques, and resources. The JewishGen.org Discussion Group makes it easy, quick, and fun, to connect with others around the world.
Is it Secure?
Yes. JewishGen is using a state of the art platform with the most contemporary security standards. JewishGen will never share member information with third parties.
How is the New JewishGen.org Discussion Group better than the old one?
Our old Discussion List platform was woefully antiquated. Among its many challenges: it was not secure, it required messages to be sent in Plain Text, did not support accented characters or languages other than English, could not display links or images, and had archives that were not mobile-friendly.
This new platform that JewishGen is using is a scalable, and sustainable solution, and allows us to engage with JewishGen members throughout the world. It offers a simple and intuitive interface for both members and moderators, more powerful tools, and more secure archives (which are easily accessible on mobile devices, and which also block out personal email addresses to the public).
I am a JewishGen member, why do I have to create a separate account for the Discussion Group?
As we continue to modernize our platform, we are trying to ensure that everything meets contemporary security standards. In the future, we plan hope to have one single sign-in page.
I like how the current lists work. Will I still be able to send/receive emails of posts (and/or digests)?
Yes. In terms of functionality, the group will operate the same for people who like to participate with email. People can still send a message to an email address (in this case, main@groups.JewishGen.org), and receive a daily digest of postings, or individual emails. In addition, Members can also receive a daily summary of topics, and then choose which topics they would like to read about it. However, in addition to email, there is the additional functionality of being able to read/post messages utilizing our online forum (https://groups.jewishgen.org).
Does this new system require plain-text?
No.
Can I post images, accented characters, different colors/font sizes, non-latin characters?
Yes.
Can I categorize a message? For example, if my message is related to Polish, or Ukraine research, can I indicate as such?
Yes! Our new platform allows members to use “Hashtags.” Messages can then be sorted, and searched, based upon how they are categorized. Another advantage is that members can “mute” any conversations they are not interested in, by simply indicating they are not interested in a particular “hashtag.”
Will all posts be archived?
Yes.
Can I still search though old messages?
Yes. All the messages are accessible and searchable going back to 1998.
What if I have questions or need assistance using the new Group?
Send your questions to: support@JewishGen.org
How do I access the Group’s webpage?
Follow this link: https://groups.jewishgen.org/g/main
So just to be sure - this new group will allow us to post from our mobile phones, includes images, accented characters, and non-latin characters, and does not require plain text?
Correct!
Will there be any ads or annoying pop-ups?
No.
Will the current guidelines change?
Yes. While posts will be moderated to ensure civility, and that there is nothing posted that is inappropriate (or completely unrelated to genealogy), we will be trying to create an online community of people who regulate themselves, much as they do (very successfully) on Jewish Genealogy Portal on Facebook.
What are the new guidelines?
There are just a few simple rules & guidelines to follow, which you can read here:https://groups.jewishgen.org/g/main/guidelines
Thank you in advance for contributing to this amazing online community!
If you have any questions, or suggestions, please email support@JewishGen.org.
Sincerely,
The JewishGen.org Team
Re: Death Records, City Directories
#general
sallybru@...
For death certificates in Elmira, try writing Vital Records City Hall
Elmira, NY. This generally works for cities anywhere in the US. For directories, try the Mormon FHL. If not there, try your local library. I know our local library central branch has a lot of old directories for a lot of places. Sally Bruckheimer Buffalo, NY
|
|
Re: Family Data Sheet Estimation Program
#general
sallybru@...
This is very interesting and may be helpful, but we need to keep in mind
(especially beginners) that sometimes families in specific locations and specific religions (Jews) did things differently. For example, I put in a marriage dates of 1652 and 1852. For 1652 it estimates that the parents were born in 1628 and 1630. That makes the husband 24 and the wife 22 at marriage. I don't know about all ethnic groups, but for many of the Ashkenazi, that is ancient. You see lots of messages on Jewishgen about marriages of people 12 and 14 years old! They are almost grandparents by 24!!! The rest are reasonable estimates, but the marriage age is far off for many of our ancestors. It is roughly reasonably for my Sephardim in Amsterdam, who married for the first time >from age 16 to 40! Sally Bruckheimer Buffalo, NY
|
|
Re: Naming Patterns
#germany
sallybru@...
Norman Carp-Gordon asks me:
How far back were your German Jewish ancestors naming children after *living* grandparents? Many German Jews began assimilating in the early 19th century. Even short of baptism and/or intermarriage liberal practices and influences >from Gentile customs became common. However, perhaps about half German Jewry remained traditional--and *rigidly* so. 1700's Norman. As has often been written (check the Archives) Western Jews did not follow the Eastern Ashkenazi on this. The Bruckheimer family, for one, lived in the same town since the late 1600's and named after the grandparents. Long before taking the surname. Another family which married them can be traced back to late in the 1700's. Sally Bruckheimer Buffalo, NY
|
|
London 2001
#general
Sam Shoshan <samshoshan@...>
When is the Jewish Jen conference in London?
MODERATOR NOTE: On our homepage, http://www.jewishgen.org/ , there is information on this conference under the heading "Hosted Organizations." The website for the conference is at http://www.jewishgen.org/London2001/
|
|
help with URLs
#general
Arlene <aparnes@...>
Please send to me privately:
any URLs you have found useful in your gen. search, especially those of Jewish interest. I've lost all of my bookmarks due to a HD crash. Many thanks for any help. Arlene Parnes, Orlando aparnes@...
|
|
Re: HIAS
#general
A. E. Jordan
Thanks for the addresses on HIAS -- I am sure a lot of us will find it
helpful. Any idea what type of records HIAS has in New York? One of my great great great uncles (Leon SANDERS) was very involved (may be a founder) of HIAS in New York. He was also active with B'rth Abraham and >from family stories met with one of the US presidents (early 1920s it sounds like) about the support of a Jewish homestate in Plaestine. He also traveled to Mexico in the 1920s to discuss Jewish immigration with the Mexican president of the time. Would love to know more about this man's work and wondering what files HIAS might have related to his work for them? Thanks. Allan Jordan
|
|
Book: La Fusion de los Sefardies con Los Dominicanos 1944
#general
r.van wijngaarden <r.van.wijngaarden@...>
Dear Genners,
Is there one of us who has read or even better, in his possession this book by Enrique UCKO called: "La Fusion De Los Sefardies Con Los Dominicanos" Printed in 1944 by C. Trujillo-Impr. La Opinion 1944. Would he/she please be so friendly as to contact me. Thanks in advance René F.van Wijngaarden Netherlands E-mail : r.van.wijngaarden@... Familytree at: http://www.geocities.com/Heartland/Creek/6534 Searching for: Del Valle/Delvalle/Van Daelen/Salom del Valle/Maduro/De Marchena/Barzilay MODERATOR NOTE: Please reply privately.
|
|
Re: Lithuanian State Historical Archives
#general
Norman H. Carp-Gordon <zerakodesh@...>
The archives in Vilnius *do* have death (and divorce) as well as birth
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
and marriage records. Moreover, you don't need to order them >from the archives. They are all on Mormon microfilms--I have a 75-page printout with all the catalogue data. If you ask me about any community, I can tell you what exists for it.
I have been successful in obtaining birth and marriage recordsfrom the Lithuanian State Historical Archives, but I have neverreceived any death records. Is this just coincidence, or are
|
|
Re: Cloning & Genealogy
#general
Dick@...
George Losonci's amusing post provides an opportunity to clarify the
distinction between genealogy and genetics. While related, they are not the same thing. Genealogy is a branch of sociology, in that genealogical relationships are culturally determined. Genetics, by contrast, is a branch of biology. A couple of examples will serve to illustrate how genetic and genealogical relationships may differ. Identical twins possess essentially the same genetic makeup, as well as nearly identical early environmental influences. Yet they are not the same person, are shown separately on family trees, have different names and legal identities, and in general are treated by our society as more different than would be warranted by considering only their genetics. Mr Losonci's hypothetical clone would of course be even more different from the original, with entirely different early environmentalexperiences. Of course the clone would be treated as an entirely different person by society. The identity of the clone's genealogical "parents" would be determined by society, either by legal fiat or by cultural consensus, and would almost certainly not be the same people as the parents of the original. Conversely, consider an actual family with which I am familiar. A young woman became pregnant by a man who would not marry her or whom she did not wish to marry. A good friend of hers, not the biological father of her fetus, married her to provide a family for her daughter (as it turned out to be). The baby was born four months after the marriage. By law, by genealogy, by actual family ties, the mother's husband was the father of the girl. Although the marriage did not last, the father-daughter relationship is still strong, although the daughter is now grown and living on her own. The father did not adopt the child (did not have to), yet is by any genealogical measure her father, although she carries none of his genes. Indeed, in most jurisdictions, the mother's husband is by law presumed to be the child's father. I believe that in some jurisdictions, at least at some times, this presumption is or was not even rebuttable. Genealogy is confused so easily with genetics because, despite anomalies such as the examples above, they do go together most of the time. It is because of this strong correlation that we can use genetics to test genealogical hypotheses, as in JewishGen's Genealogy by Genetics project. But we can't assume that the genetic test is the "gold standard" for genealogy. When a genetic test confirms or fails to confirm a presumed genealogical relationship, we have acquired just one more piece of evidence to take into account in building our family tree. The central topic of JewishGen is genealogy, the study of relationships as defined by society. To the extent that genetics can be used to help us build our genealogies, it is relevant. But genetics per se, or DNA testing in particular, is really not what JewishGen is here for. That is why discussions of genetics and DNA testing properly take place on the DNA list, not in the Discussion Group, which is reserved for discussions of genealogy. A little humor is welcome >from time to time, but serious discussions of topics such as cloning are not the focus of the JewishGen Discussion Group. Dick Plotz Providence RI USA MODERATOR NOTE: Further discussion of this issue should take place privately, or on the DNA list.
|
|
Austin Texas: OLENICK, DAVIS, FRANK, ROSENBAUM, SCHARFF
#general
Steve Axelrath <saxelrat@...>
On December 13, 1877 at age 38 my Great Great Uncle, Elias OLENICK
born in Poland, was murdered by a "Mr. Harris" in a store he owned in Austin, Texas. While Elias’ wife and children likely then moved back to New York City, others in his family stayed in the Austin area until, at least, 1979. Elias’ wife was Dora GREEN. Their children likely were Louis, Moses, Al and Lillian. Lillian married Maurice SHAPPIRO. The couple’s son, Julian SHAPPIRO, was a colleague of Edward R. Murrow’s in Europe and New York. His professional name was Joe JULIAN. The other son was Sam who lives in the Los Angeles area. In Austin, Elias’ OLENICK’S sister, Susan was married to Jacob DAVIS. Jacob had at least eight children: Sarah T, Alexander, Louis, David E., Pauline, Perl, May, and Esther. Jacob appears to have had a second wife: Fanny ROSENBAUM. Esther died in Austin in 1979. Still in the Austin area, Sarah T. DAVIS married Abraham FRANK. The children were Rosa, Aaron, Pauline, Miriam, and a girl whose name looks like Beinard. Aaron married a Gladys SCHARFF. I don't know if the other children married. Esther DAVIS, sister of Sarah T. above, married Ike ROSENFIELD. The couple once lived in Clarksville City, Texas. Many of the people named above are buried in the Oakwood Cemetery in Austin. A reference calls the cemetery Beth El #2. I’d be most interested in hearing >from anyone who might have information regarding my Texas family. I'd also be interested in hearing about "Mr. Harris," the murderer, though I suspect I wouldn't find his descendants on Jewishgen. Steve Axelrath Centennial, Colorado
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen Re: Death Records, City Directories
#general
sallybru@...
For death certificates in Elmira, try writing Vital Records City Hall
Elmira, NY. This generally works for cities anywhere in the US. For directories, try the Mormon FHL. If not there, try your local library. I know our local library central branch has a lot of old directories for a lot of places. Sally Bruckheimer Buffalo, NY
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen Re: Family Data Sheet Estimation Program
#general
sallybru@...
This is very interesting and may be helpful, but we need to keep in mind
(especially beginners) that sometimes families in specific locations and specific religions (Jews) did things differently. For example, I put in a marriage dates of 1652 and 1852. For 1652 it estimates that the parents were born in 1628 and 1630. That makes the husband 24 and the wife 22 at marriage. I don't know about all ethnic groups, but for many of the Ashkenazi, that is ancient. You see lots of messages on Jewishgen about marriages of people 12 and 14 years old! They are almost grandparents by 24!!! The rest are reasonable estimates, but the marriage age is far off for many of our ancestors. It is roughly reasonably for my Sephardim in Amsterdam, who married for the first time >from age 16 to 40! Sally Bruckheimer Buffalo, NY
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen Re: Naming Patterns
#general
sallybru@...
Norman Carp-Gordon asks me:
How far back were your German Jewish ancestors naming children after *living* grandparents? Many German Jews began assimilating in the early 19th century. Even short of baptism and/or intermarriage liberal practices and influences >from Gentile customs became common. However, perhaps about half German Jewry remained traditional--and *rigidly* so. 1700's Norman. As has often been written (check the Archives) Western Jews did not follow the Eastern Ashkenazi on this. The Bruckheimer family, for one, lived in the same town since the late 1600's and named after the grandparents. Long before taking the surname. Another family which married them can be traced back to late in the 1700's. Sally Bruckheimer Buffalo, NY
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen London 2001
#general
Sam Shoshan <samshoshan@...>
When is the Jewish Jen conference in London?
MODERATOR NOTE: On our homepage, http://www.jewishgen.org/ , there is information on this conference under the heading "Hosted Organizations." The website for the conference is at http://www.jewishgen.org/London2001/
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen help with URLs
#general
Arlene <aparnes@...>
Please send to me privately:
any URLs you have found useful in your gen. search, especially those of Jewish interest. I've lost all of my bookmarks due to a HD crash. Many thanks for any help. Arlene Parnes, Orlando aparnes@...
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen Re: HIAS
#general
A. E. Jordan
Thanks for the addresses on HIAS -- I am sure a lot of us will find it
helpful. Any idea what type of records HIAS has in New York? One of my great great great uncles (Leon SANDERS) was very involved (may be a founder) of HIAS in New York. He was also active with B'rth Abraham and >from family stories met with one of the US presidents (early 1920s it sounds like) about the support of a Jewish homestate in Plaestine. He also traveled to Mexico in the 1920s to discuss Jewish immigration with the Mexican president of the time. Would love to know more about this man's work and wondering what files HIAS might have related to his work for them? Thanks. Allan Jordan
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen Book: La Fusion de los Sefardies con Los Dominicanos 1944
#general
r.van wijngaarden <r.van.wijngaarden@...>
Dear Genners,
Is there one of us who has read or even better, in his possession this book by Enrique UCKO called: "La Fusion De Los Sefardies Con Los Dominicanos" Printed in 1944 by C. Trujillo-Impr. La Opinion 1944. Would he/she please be so friendly as to contact me. Thanks in advance René F.van Wijngaarden Netherlands E-mail : r.van.wijngaarden@... Familytree at: http://www.geocities.com/Heartland/Creek/6534 Searching for: Del Valle/Delvalle/Van Daelen/Salom del Valle/Maduro/De Marchena/Barzilay MODERATOR NOTE: Please reply privately.
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen Re: Lithuanian State Historical Archives
#general
Norman H. Carp-Gordon <zerakodesh@...>
The archives in Vilnius *do* have death (and divorce) as well as birth
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
and marriage records. Moreover, you don't need to order them >from the archives. They are all on Mormon microfilms--I have a 75-page printout with all the catalogue data. If you ask me about any community, I can tell you what exists for it.
I have been successful in obtaining birth and marriage recordsfrom the Lithuanian State Historical Archives, but I have neverreceived any death records. Is this just coincidence, or are
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen Re: Cloning & Genealogy
#general
Dick@...
George Losonci's amusing post provides an opportunity to clarify the
distinction between genealogy and genetics. While related, they are not the same thing. Genealogy is a branch of sociology, in that genealogical relationships are culturally determined. Genetics, by contrast, is a branch of biology. A couple of examples will serve to illustrate how genetic and genealogical relationships may differ. Identical twins possess essentially the same genetic makeup, as well as nearly identical early environmental influences. Yet they are not the same person, are shown separately on family trees, have different names and legal identities, and in general are treated by our society as more different than would be warranted by considering only their genetics. Mr Losonci's hypothetical clone would of course be even more different from the original, with entirely different early environmentalexperiences. Of course the clone would be treated as an entirely different person by society. The identity of the clone's genealogical "parents" would be determined by society, either by legal fiat or by cultural consensus, and would almost certainly not be the same people as the parents of the original. Conversely, consider an actual family with which I am familiar. A young woman became pregnant by a man who would not marry her or whom she did not wish to marry. A good friend of hers, not the biological father of her fetus, married her to provide a family for her daughter (as it turned out to be). The baby was born four months after the marriage. By law, by genealogy, by actual family ties, the mother's husband was the father of the girl. Although the marriage did not last, the father-daughter relationship is still strong, although the daughter is now grown and living on her own. The father did not adopt the child (did not have to), yet is by any genealogical measure her father, although she carries none of his genes. Indeed, in most jurisdictions, the mother's husband is by law presumed to be the child's father. I believe that in some jurisdictions, at least at some times, this presumption is or was not even rebuttable. Genealogy is confused so easily with genetics because, despite anomalies such as the examples above, they do go together most of the time. It is because of this strong correlation that we can use genetics to test genealogical hypotheses, as in JewishGen's Genealogy by Genetics project. But we can't assume that the genetic test is the "gold standard" for genealogy. When a genetic test confirms or fails to confirm a presumed genealogical relationship, we have acquired just one more piece of evidence to take into account in building our family tree. The central topic of JewishGen is genealogy, the study of relationships as defined by society. To the extent that genetics can be used to help us build our genealogies, it is relevant. But genetics per se, or DNA testing in particular, is really not what JewishGen is here for. That is why discussions of genetics and DNA testing properly take place on the DNA list, not in the Discussion Group, which is reserved for discussions of genealogy. A little humor is welcome >from time to time, but serious discussions of topics such as cloning are not the focus of the JewishGen Discussion Group. Dick Plotz Providence RI USA MODERATOR NOTE: Further discussion of this issue should take place privately, or on the DNA list.
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen Austin Texas: OLENICK, DAVIS, FRANK, ROSENBAUM, SCHARFF
#general
Steve Axelrath <saxelrat@...>
On December 13, 1877 at age 38 my Great Great Uncle, Elias OLENICK
born in Poland, was murdered by a "Mr. Harris" in a store he owned in Austin, Texas. While Elias’ wife and children likely then moved back to New York City, others in his family stayed in the Austin area until, at least, 1979. Elias’ wife was Dora GREEN. Their children likely were Louis, Moses, Al and Lillian. Lillian married Maurice SHAPPIRO. The couple’s son, Julian SHAPPIRO, was a colleague of Edward R. Murrow’s in Europe and New York. His professional name was Joe JULIAN. The other son was Sam who lives in the Los Angeles area. In Austin, Elias’ OLENICK’S sister, Susan was married to Jacob DAVIS. Jacob had at least eight children: Sarah T, Alexander, Louis, David E., Pauline, Perl, May, and Esther. Jacob appears to have had a second wife: Fanny ROSENBAUM. Esther died in Austin in 1979. Still in the Austin area, Sarah T. DAVIS married Abraham FRANK. The children were Rosa, Aaron, Pauline, Miriam, and a girl whose name looks like Beinard. Aaron married a Gladys SCHARFF. I don't know if the other children married. Esther DAVIS, sister of Sarah T. above, married Ike ROSENFIELD. The couple once lived in Clarksville City, Texas. Many of the people named above are buried in the Oakwood Cemetery in Austin. A reference calls the cemetery Beth El #2. I’d be most interested in hearing >from anyone who might have information regarding my Texas family. I'd also be interested in hearing about "Mr. Harris," the murderer, though I suspect I wouldn't find his descendants on Jewishgen. Steve Axelrath Centennial, Colorado
|
|