JewishGen.org Discussion Group FAQs
What is the JewishGen.org Discussion Group?
The JewishGen.org Discussion Group unites thousands of Jewish genealogical researchers worldwide as they research their family history, search for relatives, and share information, ideas, methods, tips, techniques, and resources. The JewishGen.org Discussion Group makes it easy, quick, and fun, to connect with others around the world.
Is it Secure?
Yes. JewishGen is using a state of the art platform with the most contemporary security standards. JewishGen will never share member information with third parties.
How is the New JewishGen.org Discussion Group better than the old one?
Our old Discussion List platform was woefully antiquated. Among its many challenges: it was not secure, it required messages to be sent in Plain Text, did not support accented characters or languages other than English, could not display links or images, and had archives that were not mobile-friendly.
This new platform that JewishGen is using is a scalable, and sustainable solution, and allows us to engage with JewishGen members throughout the world. It offers a simple and intuitive interface for both members and moderators, more powerful tools, and more secure archives (which are easily accessible on mobile devices, and which also block out personal email addresses to the public).
I am a JewishGen member, why do I have to create a separate account for the Discussion Group?
As we continue to modernize our platform, we are trying to ensure that everything meets contemporary security standards. In the future, we plan hope to have one single sign-in page.
I like how the current lists work. Will I still be able to send/receive emails of posts (and/or digests)?
Yes. In terms of functionality, the group will operate the same for people who like to participate with email. People can still send a message to an email address (in this case, main@groups.JewishGen.org), and receive a daily digest of postings, or individual emails. In addition, Members can also receive a daily summary of topics, and then choose which topics they would like to read about it. However, in addition to email, there is the additional functionality of being able to read/post messages utilizing our online forum (https://groups.jewishgen.org).
Does this new system require plain-text?
No.
Can I post images, accented characters, different colors/font sizes, non-latin characters?
Yes.
Can I categorize a message? For example, if my message is related to Polish, or Ukraine research, can I indicate as such?
Yes! Our new platform allows members to use “Hashtags.” Messages can then be sorted, and searched, based upon how they are categorized. Another advantage is that members can “mute” any conversations they are not interested in, by simply indicating they are not interested in a particular “hashtag.”
Will all posts be archived?
Yes.
Can I still search though old messages?
Yes. All the messages are accessible and searchable going back to 1998.
What if I have questions or need assistance using the new Group?
Send your questions to: support@JewishGen.org
How do I access the Group’s webpage?
Follow this link: https://groups.jewishgen.org/g/main
So just to be sure - this new group will allow us to post from our mobile phones, includes images, accented characters, and non-latin characters, and does not require plain text?
Correct!
Will there be any ads or annoying pop-ups?
No.
Will the current guidelines change?
Yes. While posts will be moderated to ensure civility, and that there is nothing posted that is inappropriate (or completely unrelated to genealogy), we will be trying to create an online community of people who regulate themselves, much as they do (very successfully) on Jewish Genealogy Portal on Facebook.
What are the new guidelines?
There are just a few simple rules & guidelines to follow, which you can read here:https://groups.jewishgen.org/g/main/guidelines
Thank you in advance for contributing to this amazing online community!
If you have any questions, or suggestions, please email support@JewishGen.org.
Sincerely,
The JewishGen.org Team
Re: Russia (Poland)
#general
Joan Silverman <jbsilverman@...>
Hi,
I received today a marriage certificate on my grandparents and have found several times my great grandparents place of birth is noted as Russia (Poland). Can someone help with a geography lesson and let me know what area this is pertaining to -- around 1860. Thanks for your help Joan Silverman Revere, Massachusetts mail to: jbsilverman @mediaone.net MODERATOR NOTE: This question has been addressed several times before in the JewishGen Discussion Group. You can find these discussions by searching the JewishGen Discussion Group Archives at <http://www.jewishgen.org/wconnect/wc.isa?jg~jgsys~archpop> for "Russia then Poland" (without the quotes). You will get a long list of posts. Scroll down the list for subject lines including the combination "Russia/Poland" or something similar, and click on those subject lines to read the posts. It may be helpful to right-click and open the posts in a new window in order to save the time required to redisplay the long list after reading each post.
|
|
Ellis Success not Possible With Soundex
#general
debjkay <debjkay@...>
I thought that I would share my "success" with the Ellis Island Data Base
because I think it shows the future wonderful possibilities this site holds. I had the normal problems experienced by everyone,it seems, accessing the site, registering, etc., but within about 5 min of "actual" searching (it was Friday at 5 pm PDT, so no telling) I found the passenger record for my great-great grandmother, her three daughters and one of their children. I have found passenger manifests for all in my direct line, and most collaterals by a combination of using Soundex and info on Naturalization papers, but I had reached what really would have been a dead end, if not for the Ellis site. I discovered by census-Federal and NY--that my great-great grandmother, who I thought was "left" in Europe in fact immigrated in 1906 with her daughter and infant grandson, then lived with them for 15 years. I had (finally) found her death certificate (as suggested before, I had to look in a different "borough" in NYC, as she was taken to the hospital >from her home in Manhattan during her final illness and died in the Bronx), and, >from her son-in-law's Naturalization papers found that her daughter came to the US in 1906. Three census records and her birth certificate all indicated the same year. I had searched the Soundex numerous times for her, daughter, and the grandson, with no success. Anyway, the problem was this: Her name was Pessie Lewita in the old country, Levitt or Levine in America, and Pessie was butchered to Tessie, Pieche, Poise , etc. I found the death certificate by narrowing the year, and ordering ALL "P" Levine's! For my soundex search, I used, Lewit/Levita (same code), added a T, and also Levine. I found nothing (correction, I found lots of "close" ones, which when check out were children, etc., obviously incorrect) The Ellis Island data base gave me "options" to Lewita, and brought up 490 "possibles", within 2 minutes I found "Pische Lewitan", got to the manifest, and found the year(1906), town (Siedlez), the daughter and grandson (under a different name) and two other daughters! "Lewitan" would have given a different soundex code, and, more importantly, given the number of names with L-w-t or L-v-t beginnings (not to mention other letters which would code the same) there would have been thousands of possibilities for review--Levitt itself was daunting--and I doubt that I would have ever gone through those records. The "n" ending was not present in any other record to date, including the "polish" ones, and may, in fact, be a reading error. Last part of the story, I was confident at first that I would find the daughter and baby, as her name was "Pfefferblum", and knew that there would not be as many options. For whatever reason, the daughter, Rebecca Pfefferblum, and baby, Max Pfefferblum, were traveling under the names Risoke[presumably Rivke] WILANDEK [a name I had never seen before] and Motel[ok, this is a not-so-unlikely for Max] Wilandek. Anyway, if not for the "suggestion" made by the database, I am positive that I would never have found this record. As I described above, I had done everything else [yes, I was about to check other ports of entry, though I thought this was unlikely, as other relatives had gone to NYC, and the husband of the daughter was there waiting, but I would have] and this record would have been lost. Final thought, when I first saw the "soundslike" option on the Ellis sight and the "alternatives", I was disappointed, as it appeared to be not very helpful. Was I wrong. Hope my experience can be helpful to someone. Debra Kay debjkay@... Simi Valley, CA
|
|
Re: Ellis Island Comments
#general
Shel <sbercovich@...>
Ann Rabinowitz wrote:
[snip - good stuff] 8. Due to the names being retrieved in non-sorted order, it is difficultHi all, There _is_ a way to deal with this, though for people with long lists, it's fairly tedious. 1. Bring up the list of names for which you're searching at EIDB. 2. Highlight and copy (to the clipboard) the whole list (of 25) _including_ the headings for each column. 3. Paste this into a word processor document. You'll get something like this: _ Name Residence Arrival Age 1. Joe Blow Gorky 1911 25 4. Bring up the succeeding pages and, in turn, highlight, copy and paste the _data only_ (Not the headings) onto the bottom of the wordpro file. 5. Adjust the number of lines in _each_ record so they are EXACTLY the same (This is the _really_ fiddly part, because they're not all the same and there are blank lines in between some of the columns!) Ensure there's a carriage return after each complete record. 6. ***Save this file under two different names.***. Use only the second one to do the following: 7. Use your word pro's "Text to Table" feature to make the listing into a chart or table. You may have to fiddle back and forth to get it all right, but once you do, you'll have a usable table that can be sorted "every which way 'till Sunday"! :-) I found a setting of 9 columns does the trick. Incidentally, you'll wind up with a couple of blank columns which can be deleted using the wordpro's "Table Layout" feature. You can also adjust column widths, font sizes, etc. I saved 4 different versions: a) as the list showed in the EIDB; b) by name; c) by Date of Arrival; d) added another column (you could use one of the blank columns for this) of Birth Date (lots of calculations, but it helps to sort people). Have fun, Shel Bercovich Searching: BERCOVICI, GOLDENBERG, MOSCOVICI - Darabani, Dorohoi, Iasi & Stefanesti, Romania KLEBANOV (various spellings), LIPKIND - Minsk Gubernia; NYC ECHTER (HECHTER), ZWANG - Tulchin, Botha, & Krivoye Ozero, Ukraine; Israel; Argentina
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen RE: Russia (Poland)
#general
Joan Silverman <jbsilverman@...>
Hi,
I received today a marriage certificate on my grandparents and have found several times my great grandparents place of birth is noted as Russia (Poland). Can someone help with a geography lesson and let me know what area this is pertaining to -- around 1860. Thanks for your help Joan Silverman Revere, Massachusetts mail to: jbsilverman @mediaone.net MODERATOR NOTE: This question has been addressed several times before in the JewishGen Discussion Group. You can find these discussions by searching the JewishGen Discussion Group Archives at <http://www.jewishgen.org/wconnect/wc.isa?jg~jgsys~archpop> for "Russia then Poland" (without the quotes). You will get a long list of posts. Scroll down the list for subject lines including the combination "Russia/Poland" or something similar, and click on those subject lines to read the posts. It may be helpful to right-click and open the posts in a new window in order to save the time required to redisplay the long list after reading each post.
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen Ellis Success not Possible With Soundex
#general
debjkay <debjkay@...>
I thought that I would share my "success" with the Ellis Island Data Base
because I think it shows the future wonderful possibilities this site holds. I had the normal problems experienced by everyone,it seems, accessing the site, registering, etc., but within about 5 min of "actual" searching (it was Friday at 5 pm PDT, so no telling) I found the passenger record for my great-great grandmother, her three daughters and one of their children. I have found passenger manifests for all in my direct line, and most collaterals by a combination of using Soundex and info on Naturalization papers, but I had reached what really would have been a dead end, if not for the Ellis site. I discovered by census-Federal and NY--that my great-great grandmother, who I thought was "left" in Europe in fact immigrated in 1906 with her daughter and infant grandson, then lived with them for 15 years. I had (finally) found her death certificate (as suggested before, I had to look in a different "borough" in NYC, as she was taken to the hospital >from her home in Manhattan during her final illness and died in the Bronx), and, >from her son-in-law's Naturalization papers found that her daughter came to the US in 1906. Three census records and her birth certificate all indicated the same year. I had searched the Soundex numerous times for her, daughter, and the grandson, with no success. Anyway, the problem was this: Her name was Pessie Lewita in the old country, Levitt or Levine in America, and Pessie was butchered to Tessie, Pieche, Poise , etc. I found the death certificate by narrowing the year, and ordering ALL "P" Levine's! For my soundex search, I used, Lewit/Levita (same code), added a T, and also Levine. I found nothing (correction, I found lots of "close" ones, which when check out were children, etc., obviously incorrect) The Ellis Island data base gave me "options" to Lewita, and brought up 490 "possibles", within 2 minutes I found "Pische Lewitan", got to the manifest, and found the year(1906), town (Siedlez), the daughter and grandson (under a different name) and two other daughters! "Lewitan" would have given a different soundex code, and, more importantly, given the number of names with L-w-t or L-v-t beginnings (not to mention other letters which would code the same) there would have been thousands of possibilities for review--Levitt itself was daunting--and I doubt that I would have ever gone through those records. The "n" ending was not present in any other record to date, including the "polish" ones, and may, in fact, be a reading error. Last part of the story, I was confident at first that I would find the daughter and baby, as her name was "Pfefferblum", and knew that there would not be as many options. For whatever reason, the daughter, Rebecca Pfefferblum, and baby, Max Pfefferblum, were traveling under the names Risoke[presumably Rivke] WILANDEK [a name I had never seen before] and Motel[ok, this is a not-so-unlikely for Max] Wilandek. Anyway, if not for the "suggestion" made by the database, I am positive that I would never have found this record. As I described above, I had done everything else [yes, I was about to check other ports of entry, though I thought this was unlikely, as other relatives had gone to NYC, and the husband of the daughter was there waiting, but I would have] and this record would have been lost. Final thought, when I first saw the "soundslike" option on the Ellis sight and the "alternatives", I was disappointed, as it appeared to be not very helpful. Was I wrong. Hope my experience can be helpful to someone. Debra Kay debjkay@... Simi Valley, CA
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen Re: Ellis Island Comments
#general
Shel <sbercovich@...>
Ann Rabinowitz wrote:
[snip - good stuff] 8. Due to the names being retrieved in non-sorted order, it is difficultHi all, There _is_ a way to deal with this, though for people with long lists, it's fairly tedious. 1. Bring up the list of names for which you're searching at EIDB. 2. Highlight and copy (to the clipboard) the whole list (of 25) _including_ the headings for each column. 3. Paste this into a word processor document. You'll get something like this: _ Name Residence Arrival Age 1. Joe Blow Gorky 1911 25 4. Bring up the succeeding pages and, in turn, highlight, copy and paste the _data only_ (Not the headings) onto the bottom of the wordpro file. 5. Adjust the number of lines in _each_ record so they are EXACTLY the same (This is the _really_ fiddly part, because they're not all the same and there are blank lines in between some of the columns!) Ensure there's a carriage return after each complete record. 6. ***Save this file under two different names.***. Use only the second one to do the following: 7. Use your word pro's "Text to Table" feature to make the listing into a chart or table. You may have to fiddle back and forth to get it all right, but once you do, you'll have a usable table that can be sorted "every which way 'till Sunday"! :-) I found a setting of 9 columns does the trick. Incidentally, you'll wind up with a couple of blank columns which can be deleted using the wordpro's "Table Layout" feature. You can also adjust column widths, font sizes, etc. I saved 4 different versions: a) as the list showed in the EIDB; b) by name; c) by Date of Arrival; d) added another column (you could use one of the blank columns for this) of Birth Date (lots of calculations, but it helps to sort people). Have fun, Shel Bercovich Searching: BERCOVICI, GOLDENBERG, MOSCOVICI - Darabani, Dorohoi, Iasi & Stefanesti, Romania KLEBANOV (various spellings), LIPKIND - Minsk Gubernia; NYC ECHTER (HECHTER), ZWANG - Tulchin, Botha, & Krivoye Ozero, Ukraine; Israel; Argentina
|
|
ellis island/fam search
#general
Sara Lynns
This may sound silly
I found incomplete information re: paternal grandfather stated he was not married could not find my grandmother or othe rrelatives on search Are there other resources for those arriving in NY from 1904 to 1915?todah Jackie Lerner-Aderman
|
|
re Pavlinka and PLATNICK
#general
mgglass <mgglass@...>
Dear Jewishgenners:
Is there anybody searching PLATNICK (any spelling) and Pavlinka, Ukraine (Russia) in Podolia? I have been researching both for some time and have not come up with any answers. My immediate family moved to Canada. There is a possibility that the remainder of the PLATNICK Family may have immigrated to South America. Thank you and I may reached at mgglass@.... Marilyn PLATNICK GLASS Toronto, Ontario Canada
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen ellis island/fam search
#general
Sara Lynns
This may sound silly
I found incomplete information re: paternal grandfather stated he was not married could not find my grandmother or othe rrelatives on search Are there other resources for those arriving in NY from 1904 to 1915?todah Jackie Lerner-Aderman
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen re Pavlinka and PLATNICK
#general
mgglass <mgglass@...>
Dear Jewishgenners:
Is there anybody searching PLATNICK (any spelling) and Pavlinka, Ukraine (Russia) in Podolia? I have been researching both for some time and have not come up with any answers. My immediate family moved to Canada. There is a possibility that the remainder of the PLATNICK Family may have immigrated to South America. Thank you and I may reached at mgglass@.... Marilyn PLATNICK GLASS Toronto, Ontario Canada
|
|
Ellis Island - How I Find Records
#general
Bev Potter <brpotter@...>
My approach is this:
I enter a last name on the initial search screen using my best guess as to correct spelling. Of course, there really is no correct spelling since all of our names were determined by people who likely couldn't spell or possibly even read. Our names were written down by people speaking different languages and have now been transcribed into this system using a best guess approach. If I don't get a matching result >from that initial search, Then I click "Edit" for the NAME and GENDER. There you will see a selection list of alternative spellings. I have found this to be incredibly useful. Check off multiple spellings or all spellings and run again. I have located 42 "potential members" of the same family using this method. Don't expect the name to be spelled the way you think it should be - consider other alternatives. Note that there are other Edit capabilities such as age, year of arrival, etc. These can speed up your search by narrowing the field but, they are only helpful if you are reasonably sure of when they arrived, etc. I was always told my gf arrived in 1902. Turns out he arrived in 1904. I would have missed him if I had narrowed that search criteria. Bev Potter Boulder, Co. Researching: PADERESKY, PADEROSKY, GORODINSKY, SCHULMAN, DEITCHMAN, AIDELMAN, COHEN, SPEVACK, NALEBOTSKY
|
|
Ellis Island records
#general
Niall Foley <niallf@...>
Many recent postings have commented on how difficult it is to get into
the Ellis Island records database. Here in Ireland, the best time seems to be when most Americans are in bed. This morning, Saturday 21 April I was able to access the site almost continuously >from 6 a.m. - 10.00 a.m. Greenwich Mean Time. Accordingly I was able to obtain lists of over 2,500 passengers and take screenprints of the data without too much difficulty. My search results are now stored in my "account" on the Ellis Island site and I can return to it when necessary. It is important to register before starting a search and enable "cookies" on your computer and tick the "remember details" box. This way a visitor's return visits to the site will be recognised and s/he will not have to sign in. Regards Niall Foley Dublin, Ireland.
|
|
missing markers
#general
A. E. Jordan
I guess just to prove that someone went outside and enjoyed the day <grin>
and was not pounding into the Ellis Island database, I went to a cemetery today -- non-secterian of course since it is Saturday -- and was very surprised to find that the family had never erected markers on the graves. Seems very odd. Father died in 1950 and the mother in 1994. Thge graves are there -- the office helped me find them -- but there is simply to stone. Nothing anyone here can do about it but just strikes me as very odd and sort of spooky -- if that is the right word. Guess I have some odd family members. Allan Jordan aejordan@...
|
|
Re: Ellis Island
#galicia
Bernie Hirsch <bernie06@...>
No, the actual manifest is free also. You just click on the Manifest button
once you get the details of the record. Once there you can zoom, etc. However, it is cumbersome to print it or save it as an image. The actual manifest has very interesting information like hair color, eye color, height, place of birth, ever been to the US before?, address of relative or friend going to join, etc. I did not find any of my family, but I did find my father-in-law's grandfather and his aunts. The grandfather was going to be with his son who had already immigrated -- it had his full street address. --Bernie Hirsch bernie06@... Dallas, Texas David Bajot - temp act wrote: -- Kind regards, Bernie Hirsch
|
|
EIDB second page
#general
renee1056@...
I have found my mgm before I got kicked off did not find grandfather,
but will look under name he used here in USA but could someone tell me how to get to the second page the one that states who they are going to and ticket info. Shalom Renee Marcus, Spring Hill, Fl.
|
|
misspelling in EIDB
#general
Chuck Haas <haascn@...>
As another example...
Much of my family originates >from Iasi, Romania. In the pre-WWII era this is often seen spelled as Jassy. However I did note on the entry that I located which I believe to be that for my great aunt that this was spelled as Zasi. So presumably the same "creativity" afflicts names as well. -- Charles N. Haas haas@... searching: Romania: SIMON, SIMONOVITCH, HERZKOVITZ, AVRAM France: ROSENFELD, ROSENFELD-ARON, HAAS
|
|
Images in EIDB
#general
Chuck Haas <haascn@...>
I had pretty good success at staying on for about an hour starting at
5:15am this morning (EDT, Saturday). However of about half a dozen good "hits" that I located, I found that none of them gave me the actual images of the manifest. Only the text versions were available. I also get a number of "broken link" images. I am using Internet Explorer 5.0 on a Mac. I am curious for other reports on this problem (of broken links and missing images). -- Charles N. Haas haas@... searching: Romania: SIMON, SIMONOVITCH, HERZKOVITZ, AVRAM France: ROSENFELD, ROSENFELD-ARON, HAAS
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen Ellis Island - How I Find Records
#general
Bev Potter <brpotter@...>
My approach is this:
I enter a last name on the initial search screen using my best guess as to correct spelling. Of course, there really is no correct spelling since all of our names were determined by people who likely couldn't spell or possibly even read. Our names were written down by people speaking different languages and have now been transcribed into this system using a best guess approach. If I don't get a matching result >from that initial search, Then I click "Edit" for the NAME and GENDER. There you will see a selection list of alternative spellings. I have found this to be incredibly useful. Check off multiple spellings or all spellings and run again. I have located 42 "potential members" of the same family using this method. Don't expect the name to be spelled the way you think it should be - consider other alternatives. Note that there are other Edit capabilities such as age, year of arrival, etc. These can speed up your search by narrowing the field but, they are only helpful if you are reasonably sure of when they arrived, etc. I was always told my gf arrived in 1902. Turns out he arrived in 1904. I would have missed him if I had narrowed that search criteria. Bev Potter Boulder, Co. Researching: PADERESKY, PADEROSKY, GORODINSKY, SCHULMAN, DEITCHMAN, AIDELMAN, COHEN, SPEVACK, NALEBOTSKY
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen Ellis Island records
#general
Niall Foley <niallf@...>
Many recent postings have commented on how difficult it is to get into
the Ellis Island records database. Here in Ireland, the best time seems to be when most Americans are in bed. This morning, Saturday 21 April I was able to access the site almost continuously >from 6 a.m. - 10.00 a.m. Greenwich Mean Time. Accordingly I was able to obtain lists of over 2,500 passengers and take screenprints of the data without too much difficulty. My search results are now stored in my "account" on the Ellis Island site and I can return to it when necessary. It is important to register before starting a search and enable "cookies" on your computer and tick the "remember details" box. This way a visitor's return visits to the site will be recognised and s/he will not have to sign in. Regards Niall Foley Dublin, Ireland.
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen missing markers
#general
A. E. Jordan
I guess just to prove that someone went outside and enjoyed the day <grin>
and was not pounding into the Ellis Island database, I went to a cemetery today -- non-secterian of course since it is Saturday -- and was very surprised to find that the family had never erected markers on the graves. Seems very odd. Father died in 1950 and the mother in 1994. Thge graves are there -- the office helped me find them -- but there is simply to stone. Nothing anyone here can do about it but just strikes me as very odd and sort of spooky -- if that is the right word. Guess I have some odd family members. Allan Jordan aejordan@...
|
|