JewishGen.org Discussion Group FAQs
What is the JewishGen.org Discussion Group?
The JewishGen.org Discussion Group unites thousands of Jewish genealogical researchers worldwide as they research their family history, search for relatives, and share information, ideas, methods, tips, techniques, and resources. The JewishGen.org Discussion Group makes it easy, quick, and fun, to connect with others around the world.
Is it Secure?
Yes. JewishGen is using a state of the art platform with the most contemporary security standards. JewishGen will never share member information with third parties.
How is the New JewishGen.org Discussion Group better than the old one?
Our old Discussion List platform was woefully antiquated. Among its many challenges: it was not secure, it required messages to be sent in Plain Text, did not support accented characters or languages other than English, could not display links or images, and had archives that were not mobile-friendly.
This new platform that JewishGen is using is a scalable, and sustainable solution, and allows us to engage with JewishGen members throughout the world. It offers a simple and intuitive interface for both members and moderators, more powerful tools, and more secure archives (which are easily accessible on mobile devices, and which also block out personal email addresses to the public).
I am a JewishGen member, why do I have to create a separate account for the Discussion Group?
As we continue to modernize our platform, we are trying to ensure that everything meets contemporary security standards. In the future, we plan hope to have one single sign-in page.
I like how the current lists work. Will I still be able to send/receive emails of posts (and/or digests)?
Yes. In terms of functionality, the group will operate the same for people who like to participate with email. People can still send a message to an email address (in this case, main@groups.JewishGen.org), and receive a daily digest of postings, or individual emails. In addition, Members can also receive a daily summary of topics, and then choose which topics they would like to read about it. However, in addition to email, there is the additional functionality of being able to read/post messages utilizing our online forum (https://groups.jewishgen.org).
Does this new system require plain-text?
No.
Can I post images, accented characters, different colors/font sizes, non-latin characters?
Yes.
Can I categorize a message? For example, if my message is related to Polish, or Ukraine research, can I indicate as such?
Yes! Our new platform allows members to use “Hashtags.” Messages can then be sorted, and searched, based upon how they are categorized. Another advantage is that members can “mute” any conversations they are not interested in, by simply indicating they are not interested in a particular “hashtag.”
Will all posts be archived?
Yes.
Can I still search though old messages?
Yes. All the messages are accessible and searchable going back to 1998.
What if I have questions or need assistance using the new Group?
Send your questions to: support@JewishGen.org
How do I access the Group’s webpage?
Follow this link: https://groups.jewishgen.org/g/main
So just to be sure - this new group will allow us to post from our mobile phones, includes images, accented characters, and non-latin characters, and does not require plain text?
Correct!
Will there be any ads or annoying pop-ups?
No.
Will the current guidelines change?
Yes. While posts will be moderated to ensure civility, and that there is nothing posted that is inappropriate (or completely unrelated to genealogy), we will be trying to create an online community of people who regulate themselves, much as they do (very successfully) on Jewish Genealogy Portal on Facebook.
What are the new guidelines?
There are just a few simple rules & guidelines to follow, which you can read here:https://groups.jewishgen.org/g/main/guidelines
Thank you in advance for contributing to this amazing online community!
If you have any questions, or suggestions, please email support@JewishGen.org.
Sincerely,
The JewishGen.org Team
Re: Naturalization Applications, early 1900's (BERELOWITZ)
#southafrica
Ann Rabinowitz <annrab@...>
I am curious whether you have posted on this digest about your relatives
from the Ukraine? How do you know they came to South Africa? When did theycome? Were they perhaps part of the Ochberg Orphans group >from the Ukraine? Ann Rabinowitz annrab@bellsouth.net
|
|
South Africa SIG #SouthAfrica RE: Naturalization Applications, early 1900's (BERELOWITZ)
#southafrica
Ann Rabinowitz <annrab@...>
I am curious whether you have posted on this digest about your relatives
from the Ukraine? How do you know they came to South Africa? When did theycome? Were they perhaps part of the Ochberg Orphans group >from the Ukraine? Ann Rabinowitz annrab@bellsouth.net
|
|
Odp: Re: How to recruit JewishGenners in Russia, Poland or Ukraine
#general
Julia Koszewska <julia_koszewska@...>
Dear Genners,
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
We have talked about it several times. If u need some help >from Poland I'm native polish speaker and i live here- in capital of Poland, Warsaw. and i hope i'll be able to help U, so please contact me privately if u need something >from Poland or maybe some translations >from polish into english (or french). if i only have time i'm translating some polish records which u post on JewishGen. but if u need some official organization >from Poland, there is still an agenda of Lauder Foundation, which with cooperation with national Jewish Historical Institute has genealogical branch- specialized of course wish Jewish roots in Poland (or former area of Poland). People who work for this branch of Lauder's Foundation are members of this discussion group. Best regards- Julia
"mark" < mark306@bezeqint.net > wrote in message
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen Odp: Re: How to recruit JewishGenners in Russia, Poland or Ukraine
#general
Julia Koszewska <julia_koszewska@...>
Dear Genners,
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
We have talked about it several times. If u need some help >from Poland I'm native polish speaker and i live here- in capital of Poland, Warsaw. and i hope i'll be able to help U, so please contact me privately if u need something >from Poland or maybe some translations >from polish into english (or french). if i only have time i'm translating some polish records which u post on JewishGen. but if u need some official organization >from Poland, there is still an agenda of Lauder Foundation, which with cooperation with national Jewish Historical Institute has genealogical branch- specialized of course wish Jewish roots in Poland (or former area of Poland). People who work for this branch of Lauder's Foundation are members of this discussion group. Best regards- Julia
"mark" < mark306@bezeqint.net > wrote in message
|
|
Mlada Boleslav Cemetery
#austria-czech
peter bakos <pgbakos@...>
Hi Fellow Siggers,
Last week I finally had the chance to visit Mlada Boleslav (formerly Jung Bunzlau) the home of the Podwinecz family as far as is known. The archivist there is very kind and I will be going back next week to see the local census >from 1910 and other records she needed some days to obtain. She showed me a geography of Bohemia which listed the towns and showed the names of the lords. The Freiherren von Waldstein owned 20 towns in the area one of which is called Podwinecz but which I cannot find on any map. I am fascinated by the connection but have no idea if there were Jewish people living in that village. I also visited the cemetery in Jung Bunzlau, which is guarded by a very kind man and his wife. I think he is a school teacher. They have a photocopied print of the guide to the cemetery done in 1891 by Herman Pollak, called Plan fur die am Ende des Jahres 5651 auf dem israelitischen Friedhofe zu Jungbunzlau. The lisitings give a name, foowed usually by a comma and another name, then a comma and the year, then the row and column number indicating the place of burial. Many of the older stones are broken and indecipherable >from wear, much less being in Hebrew, which I cannot read. I am also bewildered by some names and hope someone can shed light on the following: Berocho, Susskind, Jentel, Gedaliah, Feisch Ber, Chajele, Lejb, Liebe, Liebele, Bogelli, Abdon, Fradl, Iechel, Uwizdor, Brodl. I also do not understand what a third name in the oisting means, but suppose it is the maiden name of a wife. I hope someone will be able to help. Thanks Peter Bakos Budapest, at least for now
|
|
Austria-Czech SIG #Austria-Czech Mlada Boleslav Cemetery
#austria-czech
peter bakos <pgbakos@...>
Hi Fellow Siggers,
Last week I finally had the chance to visit Mlada Boleslav (formerly Jung Bunzlau) the home of the Podwinecz family as far as is known. The archivist there is very kind and I will be going back next week to see the local census >from 1910 and other records she needed some days to obtain. She showed me a geography of Bohemia which listed the towns and showed the names of the lords. The Freiherren von Waldstein owned 20 towns in the area one of which is called Podwinecz but which I cannot find on any map. I am fascinated by the connection but have no idea if there were Jewish people living in that village. I also visited the cemetery in Jung Bunzlau, which is guarded by a very kind man and his wife. I think he is a school teacher. They have a photocopied print of the guide to the cemetery done in 1891 by Herman Pollak, called Plan fur die am Ende des Jahres 5651 auf dem israelitischen Friedhofe zu Jungbunzlau. The lisitings give a name, foowed usually by a comma and another name, then a comma and the year, then the row and column number indicating the place of burial. Many of the older stones are broken and indecipherable >from wear, much less being in Hebrew, which I cannot read. I am also bewildered by some names and hope someone can shed light on the following: Berocho, Susskind, Jentel, Gedaliah, Feisch Ber, Chajele, Lejb, Liebe, Liebele, Bogelli, Abdon, Fradl, Iechel, Uwizdor, Brodl. I also do not understand what a third name in the oisting means, but suppose it is the maiden name of a wife. I hope someone will be able to help. Thanks Peter Bakos Budapest, at least for now
|
|
"Emigration House" Opens in Bremerhaven
#general
Pamela Weisberger <pweisberger@...>
There's a story of interest to researchers in today's New York Times about
emigration >from the port of Bremerhaven, and a new museum, known in German as Deutsches Auswanderer Haus--or "Emigration House"--which opened in that city a few weeks ago. The story can be read at: http://www.nytimes.com/2005/09/02/international/europe/02bremerhaven.html This museum tells the flip side of the experiences detailed at New York's Ellis Island Museum--the departure of our ancestors to a new, unknown world, versus their arrival in a strange land. And in this case, they were not just heading to New York, but to ports in Canada, Brazil, Argentina and Australia. Although Hamburg has been planning an emigration museum for years (now scheduled to open in 2007), Bremerhaven's is the first to open in Europe. You can learn more about it on the website: http://www.dah-bremerhaven.de/english/hauptseite.html It is interesting to note that Bremerhaven came into existence as a major port to accommodate the overflow demand on the port of Hamburg, and its prominence was due to efforts of one man, a Jew named Albert Ballin, who took over the operations of his father's ticket-booking service and eventually became general director of HAPAG, which is still one of Europe's biggest shipping companies. The complex he also built in Hamburg, on an island in the middle of the Elbe River once held over 30 buildings, including dormitories, a bathhouse, and a synagogue where housed people during their layovers between arriving in Germany and departing for various ports. The new Bremerhaven Auswanderer Haus is currently simulating the immigrant experience for visitors, and introducing them to a specific immigrant by providing a magnetic card with the story of one specific person, and detailing each person's life story. On their website you can take a virtual "tour" of the museum, and if you visit in person, they appear to have a computer center called "forum migration" where you can use their database and archives to "research your ancestors and discover the meaning of your family's name." There does not appear to be any online research available on the museum's website. Also of interest might be the German Emigrants Database at the Historisches Museum Bremerhaven at: http://www.historisches-museum-bremerhaven.de/index.php?id=128 which contains information on emigrants who left Europe for the United States of America between 1820 and 1939, primarily >from German ports, taken from passenger manifests.This new museum might be a destination one might want to add to a European itinerary to gain another perspective into our ancestors' emigration experience. Pamela Weisberger Santa Monica, CA pweisberger@hotmail.com
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen "Emigration House" Opens in Bremerhaven
#general
Pamela Weisberger <pweisberger@...>
There's a story of interest to researchers in today's New York Times about
emigration >from the port of Bremerhaven, and a new museum, known in German as Deutsches Auswanderer Haus--or "Emigration House"--which opened in that city a few weeks ago. The story can be read at: http://www.nytimes.com/2005/09/02/international/europe/02bremerhaven.html This museum tells the flip side of the experiences detailed at New York's Ellis Island Museum--the departure of our ancestors to a new, unknown world, versus their arrival in a strange land. And in this case, they were not just heading to New York, but to ports in Canada, Brazil, Argentina and Australia. Although Hamburg has been planning an emigration museum for years (now scheduled to open in 2007), Bremerhaven's is the first to open in Europe. You can learn more about it on the website: http://www.dah-bremerhaven.de/english/hauptseite.html It is interesting to note that Bremerhaven came into existence as a major port to accommodate the overflow demand on the port of Hamburg, and its prominence was due to efforts of one man, a Jew named Albert Ballin, who took over the operations of his father's ticket-booking service and eventually became general director of HAPAG, which is still one of Europe's biggest shipping companies. The complex he also built in Hamburg, on an island in the middle of the Elbe River once held over 30 buildings, including dormitories, a bathhouse, and a synagogue where housed people during their layovers between arriving in Germany and departing for various ports. The new Bremerhaven Auswanderer Haus is currently simulating the immigrant experience for visitors, and introducing them to a specific immigrant by providing a magnetic card with the story of one specific person, and detailing each person's life story. On their website you can take a virtual "tour" of the museum, and if you visit in person, they appear to have a computer center called "forum migration" where you can use their database and archives to "research your ancestors and discover the meaning of your family's name." There does not appear to be any online research available on the museum's website. Also of interest might be the German Emigrants Database at the Historisches Museum Bremerhaven at: http://www.historisches-museum-bremerhaven.de/index.php?id=128 which contains information on emigrants who left Europe for the United States of America between 1820 and 1939, primarily >from German ports, taken from passenger manifests.This new museum might be a destination one might want to add to a European itinerary to gain another perspective into our ancestors' emigration experience. Pamela Weisberger Santa Monica, CA pweisberger@hotmail.com
|
|
Deathindexes.com (TITNER in Minnesota)
#general
m leonards <m_leonards@...>
Jill Ullman is looking for information about her TITNER family >from
Minnesota. I'd like to remind everyone about the site deathindexes.com, which is a regularly updated list of death indexes available for all the states. Clicking on Minnesota reveals that the large fee-based commercial site has an index to Minnesota deaths. But the Minnesota Historical Society also has a free index covering 1905--1996 (I'm not sure whether it's complete). A search on TITNER (Soundex) reveals entries for Sam TETNER, who died in Hennepin County in 1946, and for Harry TITNER, who died there in 1962. Harry's mother's maiden name was RABINOWITZ. There is also Lottie TITNER, who died in 1960. Unfortunately, it appears that her mother's maiden name was "unknown". According to the site, the actual certificate should include more information, including the decedant's father's and/or spouse's name. Of course, there are no guarantees--as we all know, death certificates are often incomplete. The site provides an easy way to order copies of the certificates for a very reasonable $8 each. Good luck in your research! Monica Leonards suburban Philadelphia
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen Deathindexes.com (TITNER in Minnesota)
#general
m leonards <m_leonards@...>
Jill Ullman is looking for information about her TITNER family >from
Minnesota. I'd like to remind everyone about the site deathindexes.com, which is a regularly updated list of death indexes available for all the states. Clicking on Minnesota reveals that the large fee-based commercial site has an index to Minnesota deaths. But the Minnesota Historical Society also has a free index covering 1905--1996 (I'm not sure whether it's complete). A search on TITNER (Soundex) reveals entries for Sam TETNER, who died in Hennepin County in 1946, and for Harry TITNER, who died there in 1962. Harry's mother's maiden name was RABINOWITZ. There is also Lottie TITNER, who died in 1960. Unfortunately, it appears that her mother's maiden name was "unknown". According to the site, the actual certificate should include more information, including the decedant's father's and/or spouse's name. Of course, there are no guarantees--as we all know, death certificates are often incomplete. The site provides an easy way to order copies of the certificates for a very reasonable $8 each. Good luck in your research! Monica Leonards suburban Philadelphia
|
|
Interview with Stuart Tower,
#general
Merle Kastner <merlek@...>
Stuart TOWER, author of "The Wayfarers",
was the JGS of Montreal's featured speaker in May, 2005. On Saturday, September 3rd, 2005, at 8:30am (EST) journalist Leslie Lutsky's radio interview with Stuart Tower will be broadcast on Montreal radio and can be listened to online at: http://www.radiocentreville.com/ *For Montrealers - please set your dial at 102.3 FM at 8:30am* on Saturday, September 3rd to hear this interesting and informative interview! ~~~ Merle Kastner JGS of Montreal, Programming merlek@videotron.ca ~~~
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen Interview with Stuart Tower,
#general
Merle Kastner <merlek@...>
Stuart TOWER, author of "The Wayfarers",
was the JGS of Montreal's featured speaker in May, 2005. On Saturday, September 3rd, 2005, at 8:30am (EST) journalist Leslie Lutsky's radio interview with Stuart Tower will be broadcast on Montreal radio and can be listened to online at: http://www.radiocentreville.com/ *For Montrealers - please set your dial at 102.3 FM at 8:30am* on Saturday, September 3rd to hear this interesting and informative interview! ~~~ Merle Kastner JGS of Montreal, Programming merlek@videotron.ca ~~~
|
|
Matrilineal Ancestry [was: Female's patrilineal ancestry]
#dna
mhlcswc2@...
On 2005.08.31, Elzbieta Kniaz <kniaziniaela@yahoo.co.uk> asked:
As a female can I check my ancestry on my father's side?I've just gotten "The Seven Daughters Of Eve" by Sykes >from my library. It has been recommended to me by people on this list as it discusses tracing females >from females, Mitochondrial DNA. I know that this question has been answered and I thought that I had saved it but I can't find it. If you google MtDNA you get a lot of results. Marcia Hoffman Baltimore, MD
|
|
DNA Research #DNA Matrilineal Ancestry [was: Female's patrilineal ancestry]
#dna
mhlcswc2@...
On 2005.08.31, Elzbieta Kniaz <kniaziniaela@yahoo.co.uk> asked:
As a female can I check my ancestry on my father's side?I've just gotten "The Seven Daughters Of Eve" by Sykes >from my library. It has been recommended to me by people on this list as it discusses tracing females >from females, Mitochondrial DNA. I know that this question has been answered and I thought that I had saved it but I can't find it. If you google MtDNA you get a lot of results. Marcia Hoffman Baltimore, MD
|
|
3 great grandchildren & 2 great great grandchildren of Gadaliah Reznik meet
#ukraine
Rose Feldman <rosef@...>
I wish to relate a success story to encourage those of you who are at a
brick wall. For my parents 50th anniversary in 1985 I did my first family tree. My father had an excellent memory and gave me info back to his great grandfather. When the Yad Vashem database went out line I wrote to a woman in the Ukraine and a woman in NY who had immigrate >from Russia. Berta, the daughter of the woman in the Ukraine turns out to be my second cousin. Her grandfather and my grandmother were brother and sister. Zila, the woman in NY is her aunt - my first cousin once removed(?). We exchanged letters and info. Then the daughter of another second cousin I knew nothing about wrote to the woman in NY to do a family tree and Zila told her to contact me. It seems that she immigrated to Israel about 12 years ago and didn't know she had family here. After her, her parents came. Last week we had a meeting in Jerusalem with Berta who is here visiting >from the Ukraine, Anatoly her cousin (my second) who lives here, his daughter and...... another second cousin once removed (she is the descendant >from a third child of my great grandfather, who knows Anatloy's family in Jerusalem but didn't know she was related, not once but twice. Once throught the Reznik line and once through the Kaminsky line. Now we just have to find descendants of the 4 other children of our great grandfather. Really unbelievable! So don't give up hope, and keep searching now. If you think a generation or two ago our relatives scattered when leaving the Ukraine, the younger generation has scattered over even a wider part of the world. Rose Feldman GITNER, REZNIK Litin & Kalinovka Ukraine EPSTEIN, BOYARKSY Ruzhany, Kossovo, Mscibow Belarus TREPPER, TREPMAN, FELDMAN, LICHT, SOICHER, SLOVIK, SZPERBER, ORENSTEIN Warsaw Poland
|
|
Ukraine SIG #Ukraine 3 great grandchildren & 2 great great grandchildren of Gadaliah Reznik meet
#ukraine
Rose Feldman <rosef@...>
I wish to relate a success story to encourage those of you who are at a
brick wall. For my parents 50th anniversary in 1985 I did my first family tree. My father had an excellent memory and gave me info back to his great grandfather. When the Yad Vashem database went out line I wrote to a woman in the Ukraine and a woman in NY who had immigrate >from Russia. Berta, the daughter of the woman in the Ukraine turns out to be my second cousin. Her grandfather and my grandmother were brother and sister. Zila, the woman in NY is her aunt - my first cousin once removed(?). We exchanged letters and info. Then the daughter of another second cousin I knew nothing about wrote to the woman in NY to do a family tree and Zila told her to contact me. It seems that she immigrated to Israel about 12 years ago and didn't know she had family here. After her, her parents came. Last week we had a meeting in Jerusalem with Berta who is here visiting >from the Ukraine, Anatoly her cousin (my second) who lives here, his daughter and...... another second cousin once removed (she is the descendant >from a third child of my great grandfather, who knows Anatloy's family in Jerusalem but didn't know she was related, not once but twice. Once throught the Reznik line and once through the Kaminsky line. Now we just have to find descendants of the 4 other children of our great grandfather. Really unbelievable! So don't give up hope, and keep searching now. If you think a generation or two ago our relatives scattered when leaving the Ukraine, the younger generation has scattered over even a wider part of the world. Rose Feldman GITNER, REZNIK Litin & Kalinovka Ukraine EPSTEIN, BOYARKSY Ruzhany, Kossovo, Mscibow Belarus TREPPER, TREPMAN, FELDMAN, LICHT, SOICHER, SLOVIK, SZPERBER, ORENSTEIN Warsaw Poland
|
|
Re: Cemetery Offices
#general
Sally Bruckheimer <sallybruc@...>
I went to a couple NY cemeteries, maybe 10 years ago,
and they were very helpful(I didn't call ahead). I went on a Sunday, which is the day I thought the staff would be there, and they were. They had records of who was buried where - I got maps to my gr grandparents' plots, and when I found my gr grandmother's foster mother in one, I ran back and found out that her husband was buried many years before she was (1864), elsewhere in the cemetery. Actually I had phoned one of the cemeteries a few years before that, and the staff gave me my gr grandfather's death date over the phone. So my experience was very positive. The cemeteries I dealt with were very helpful. Sally Bruckheimer Bridgewater, NJ
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen Re: Cemetery Offices
#general
Sally Bruckheimer <sallybruc@...>
I went to a couple NY cemeteries, maybe 10 years ago,
and they were very helpful(I didn't call ahead). I went on a Sunday, which is the day I thought the staff would be there, and they were. They had records of who was buried where - I got maps to my gr grandparents' plots, and when I found my gr grandmother's foster mother in one, I ran back and found out that her husband was buried many years before she was (1864), elsewhere in the cemetery. Actually I had phoned one of the cemeteries a few years before that, and the staff gave me my gr grandfather's death date over the phone. So my experience was very positive. The cemeteries I dealt with were very helpful. Sally Bruckheimer Bridgewater, NJ
|
|
Creation of shipping manifests?
#general
Doug Mason
I very recently posted an enquiry asking how a ship's Manifest (passenger
list) was compiled. I have thought about this a bit more, and want to share my thoughts so people can correct me and can help my understanding. The question was raised in my mind because the name "Sam" was miswritten on a Manifest as "Lain". A completely understandable mistake, if the source used by the author of the Manifest was a written document. The person named "Lain" was not a passenger. He was the husband of a passenger, whom she was going to join in USA. Her husband had already been in USA for about 5 years. Hence the error has nothing to do with an indexer of the Ellis Island record. The actual manifest is typed, not handwritten. To see it, search for Alta MANDELBAUM. She arrived on the "Baltic" in November 1920. Searches for other arrivals of the "Baltic" around that time show that the Manifests for those journeys are also typed. (The only handwritten entries are for the names of the members of the crew.) Presumably, comparisons of handwriting for several journeys of another ship might also show all their Manifests were written by the one person. This shows me that a Manifest was created by the management of the ship, not by the US Immigration service. This is corroborated by the fact that the Commander or Master signs an Affidavit before the Immigration Officer certifying to the correctness of his Manifest. I assume, therefore, that the ship's company created the Manifest either before the ship departed for USA or it was compiled on board. Presumably, the writer of a Manifest had access to passengers' documents and to information provided orally. How were questions posed to passengers who could not speak English? How did those passengers respond? The fact that "Lain" is a written error, rather than an oral error, indicates information was provided in writing. Alta gives her father's surname as "Lukerblatt". The father of her sister has the same name. But her sister's surname is given as "Fukerblatt". Clearly a written source was used by the writer of the Manifest. Perhaps someone knows the name(s) of sister ships to the "Baltic" and could tell me if their Manifests were also typed, perhaps on the same typewriter. It would be better to search for journeys taken in the period 1919 to 1921. Since Manifests were compiled >from primary sources (written and oral), Manifests are a secondary source. It is obviously far better if possible to locate the passenger's application for Naturalization, since this is a primary source. A Manifest provided a standardised format for providing information to the Immigration bureaucracy. I am simply trying to make a sense of this for myself. I was once told: "a text without a context is a pretext". Doug Mason Melbourne Australia
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen Creation of shipping manifests?
#general
Doug Mason
I very recently posted an enquiry asking how a ship's Manifest (passenger
list) was compiled. I have thought about this a bit more, and want to share my thoughts so people can correct me and can help my understanding. The question was raised in my mind because the name "Sam" was miswritten on a Manifest as "Lain". A completely understandable mistake, if the source used by the author of the Manifest was a written document. The person named "Lain" was not a passenger. He was the husband of a passenger, whom she was going to join in USA. Her husband had already been in USA for about 5 years. Hence the error has nothing to do with an indexer of the Ellis Island record. The actual manifest is typed, not handwritten. To see it, search for Alta MANDELBAUM. She arrived on the "Baltic" in November 1920. Searches for other arrivals of the "Baltic" around that time show that the Manifests for those journeys are also typed. (The only handwritten entries are for the names of the members of the crew.) Presumably, comparisons of handwriting for several journeys of another ship might also show all their Manifests were written by the one person. This shows me that a Manifest was created by the management of the ship, not by the US Immigration service. This is corroborated by the fact that the Commander or Master signs an Affidavit before the Immigration Officer certifying to the correctness of his Manifest. I assume, therefore, that the ship's company created the Manifest either before the ship departed for USA or it was compiled on board. Presumably, the writer of a Manifest had access to passengers' documents and to information provided orally. How were questions posed to passengers who could not speak English? How did those passengers respond? The fact that "Lain" is a written error, rather than an oral error, indicates information was provided in writing. Alta gives her father's surname as "Lukerblatt". The father of her sister has the same name. But her sister's surname is given as "Fukerblatt". Clearly a written source was used by the writer of the Manifest. Perhaps someone knows the name(s) of sister ships to the "Baltic" and could tell me if their Manifests were also typed, perhaps on the same typewriter. It would be better to search for journeys taken in the period 1919 to 1921. Since Manifests were compiled >from primary sources (written and oral), Manifests are a secondary source. It is obviously far better if possible to locate the passenger's application for Naturalization, since this is a primary source. A Manifest provided a standardised format for providing information to the Immigration bureaucracy. I am simply trying to make a sense of this for myself. I was once told: "a text without a context is a pretext". Doug Mason Melbourne Australia
|
|