JewishGen.org Discussion Group FAQs
What is the JewishGen.org Discussion Group?
The JewishGen.org Discussion Group unites thousands of Jewish genealogical researchers worldwide as they research their family history, search for relatives, and share information, ideas, methods, tips, techniques, and resources. The JewishGen.org Discussion Group makes it easy, quick, and fun, to connect with others around the world.
Is it Secure?
Yes. JewishGen is using a state of the art platform with the most contemporary security standards. JewishGen will never share member information with third parties.
How is the New JewishGen.org Discussion Group better than the old one?
Our old Discussion List platform was woefully antiquated. Among its many challenges: it was not secure, it required messages to be sent in Plain Text, did not support accented characters or languages other than English, could not display links or images, and had archives that were not mobile-friendly.
This new platform that JewishGen is using is a scalable, and sustainable solution, and allows us to engage with JewishGen members throughout the world. It offers a simple and intuitive interface for both members and moderators, more powerful tools, and more secure archives (which are easily accessible on mobile devices, and which also block out personal email addresses to the public).
I am a JewishGen member, why do I have to create a separate account for the Discussion Group?
As we continue to modernize our platform, we are trying to ensure that everything meets contemporary security standards. In the future, we plan hope to have one single sign-in page.
I like how the current lists work. Will I still be able to send/receive emails of posts (and/or digests)?
Yes. In terms of functionality, the group will operate the same for people who like to participate with email. People can still send a message to an email address (in this case, main@groups.JewishGen.org), and receive a daily digest of postings, or individual emails. In addition, Members can also receive a daily summary of topics, and then choose which topics they would like to read about it. However, in addition to email, there is the additional functionality of being able to read/post messages utilizing our online forum (https://groups.jewishgen.org).
Does this new system require plain-text?
No.
Can I post images, accented characters, different colors/font sizes, non-latin characters?
Yes.
Can I categorize a message? For example, if my message is related to Polish, or Ukraine research, can I indicate as such?
Yes! Our new platform allows members to use “Hashtags.” Messages can then be sorted, and searched, based upon how they are categorized. Another advantage is that members can “mute” any conversations they are not interested in, by simply indicating they are not interested in a particular “hashtag.”
Will all posts be archived?
Yes.
Can I still search though old messages?
Yes. All the messages are accessible and searchable going back to 1998.
What if I have questions or need assistance using the new Group?
Send your questions to: support@JewishGen.org
How do I access the Group’s webpage?
Follow this link: https://groups.jewishgen.org/g/main
So just to be sure - this new group will allow us to post from our mobile phones, includes images, accented characters, and non-latin characters, and does not require plain text?
Correct!
Will there be any ads or annoying pop-ups?
No.
Will the current guidelines change?
Yes. While posts will be moderated to ensure civility, and that there is nothing posted that is inappropriate (or completely unrelated to genealogy), we will be trying to create an online community of people who regulate themselves, much as they do (very successfully) on Jewish Genealogy Portal on Facebook.
What are the new guidelines?
There are just a few simple rules & guidelines to follow, which you can read here:https://groups.jewishgen.org/g/main/guidelines
Thank you in advance for contributing to this amazing online community!
If you have any questions, or suggestions, please email support@JewishGen.org.
Sincerely,
The JewishGen.org Team
Roni S. Liebowitz
The Belchatow Birds-of-a-Feather (BOF) will hold its annual meeting at the
IAJGS International Genealogy Conference on Tuesday at 4:45-6:00 in the Soho Room on the 7th floor of the Marriott Marquis Hotel, following the Lodz Area Research Group (LARG) meeting. Belchatow is part of the Lodz Area Research Group, so I suggest if you are researching Belchatow, try to attend both sessions. Groholice which was once a separate town is now part of Belchatow and included in this BOF meeting. Belchatow is located approximately 27 miles south of Lodz in Poland. Nearby Jewish towns and villages include: Kamiensk, Lask, Pabianice, Piotrkow Trybunalski, Radomsko, Rozprza, Sulejow (Silev), Sulmierzyce, Szczercow, Tomaszow Mazowiecki, Tuszyn, Widawa, and Zelow. See thee ShtetLink site for more information: http://www.jri-Poland.org/belchatow.htm . (Recently, the site has been taking longer to load on some browsers. Please be patient and give it time to download the home page. I am working on correcting this issue). If you are planning to join us, please sign-up at: http://www.shtetlinks.jewishgen.org/Lodz/signup.htm DO NOT enter your spouse's name if he/she is not attending or has no roots within Belchatow (or any of the LARG towns). List the surnames you are researching from Belchatow. This is the signup for both LARG and Belchatow researchers. You can also see who else is planning to attend, by clicking on "click here to see who is going to be there" at the bottom of the sign-in page. Even if you cannot attend this meeting due to conflicts in your schedule, please indicate the surnames you are looking for in Belchatow so that others at the meeting can contact you. I am also requesting that if you have records for surnames that others in the group are researching, please bring copies to share with them. We will be reviewing new projects for Belchatow. One major project will be initiated soon. I look forward to seeing everyone again and meeting "new" Belchatow researchers who have not attended this meeting before. Be sure to check out the Belchatow websites below. See you in August, Roni Roni Seibel Liebowitz IAJGS 2006 Conference Registration Chair and Exhibit Coordinator http://www.jgsny2006.org registration@jgsny2006.org Roni@jgsny2006.org Belchatow ShtetLink http://www.shtetlinks.jewishgen.org/belchatow/ Belchatow Shtetl CO-OP, Jewish Records Indexing- Poland, http://www.jri-Poland.org/belchatow.htm Belchatow Yizkor Book Project http://www.jewishgen.org/yizkor/Belchatow/Belchatow.html Lodz ShtetLinks http://www.shtetlinks.jewishgen.org/Lodz/index.htm Lodz Area Research Group (LARG) http://www.shtetlinks.jewishgen.org/Lodz/LARG.htm
|
|
Roni S. Liebowitz
The Belchatow Birds-of-a-Feather (BOF) will hold its annual meeting at the
IAJGS International Genealogy Conference on Tuesday at 4:45-6:00 in the Soho Room on the 7th floor of the Marriott Marquis Hotel, following the Lodz Area Research Group (LARG) meeting. Belchatow is part of the Lodz Area Research Group, so I suggest if you are researching Belchatow, try to attend both sessions. Groholice which was once a separate town is now part of Belchatow and included in this BOF meeting. Belchatow is located approximately 27 miles south of Lodz in Poland. Nearby Jewish towns and villages include: Kamiensk, Lask, Pabianice, Piotrkow Trybunalski, Radomsko, Rozprza, Sulejow (Silev), Sulmierzyce, Szczercow, Tomaszow Mazowiecki, Tuszyn, Widawa, and Zelow. See thee ShtetLink site for more information: http://www.jri-Poland.org/belchatow.htm . (Recently, the site has been taking longer to load on some browsers. Please be patient and give it time to download the home page. I am working on correcting this issue). If you are planning to join us, please sign-up at: http://www.shtetlinks.jewishgen.org/Lodz/signup.htm DO NOT enter your spouse's name if he/she is not attending or has no roots within Belchatow (or any of the LARG towns). List the surnames you are researching from Belchatow. This is the signup for both LARG and Belchatow researchers. You can also see who else is planning to attend, by clicking on "click here to see who is going to be there" at the bottom of the sign-in page. Even if you cannot attend this meeting due to conflicts in your schedule, please indicate the surnames you are looking for in Belchatow so that others at the meeting can contact you. I am also requesting that if you have records for surnames that others in the group are researching, please bring copies to share with them. We will be reviewing new projects for Belchatow. One major project will be initiated soon. I look forward to seeing everyone again and meeting "new" Belchatow researchers who have not attended this meeting before. Be sure to check out the Belchatow websites below. See you in August, Roni Roni Seibel Liebowitz IAJGS 2006 Conference Registration Chair and Exhibit Coordinator http://www.jgsny2006.org registration@jgsny2006.org Roni@jgsny2006.org Belchatow ShtetLink http://www.shtetlinks.jewishgen.org/belchatow/ Belchatow Shtetl CO-OP, Jewish Records Indexing- Poland, http://www.jri-Poland.org/belchatow.htm Belchatow Yizkor Book Project http://www.jewishgen.org/yizkor/Belchatow/Belchatow.html Lodz ShtetLinks http://www.shtetlinks.jewishgen.org/Lodz/index.htm Lodz Area Research Group (LARG) http://www.shtetlinks.jewishgen.org/Lodz/LARG.htm
|
|
Keith Hatfield <hatfield.1@...>
I am searcging for relatives of a Josef HOFFMAN born in Habry,
Czechoslovakia in 1860 to Alois Eljiezer and Therese Rivka. HOFFMAN. I believe that his son was Khaim Yekhil / Chaim HOFFMAN, who had recorded his details on the Yad Vashem site. Khaim Yekhil was I believe the husband of my Mother's Aunt Ida ADLER born in Lodz, Poland 14.1.1909. Does any one recognise these names? Regards Sherry Hatfield
|
|
Roni S. Liebowitz
The Lodz Area Research Group will hold its annual meeting at the Conference
on Tuesday at 3:15-4:30 in the Soho Room on the 7th floor of the Marriott Marquis Hotel. This is a group researching not only the city of Lodz, but approximately 80 surrounding towns. To see if this includes one of your towns in Poland, go to www.shtetlinks.jewishgen.org/Lodz/LARG.htm, click on towns, and scroll down for the list. If you are planning to join us, please sign-up at: http://www.shtetlinks.jewishgen.org/Lodz/signup.htm DO NOT enter your spouse's name if he/she is not attending or has no roots within these towns. List the surnames and towns you are researching ONLY >from this area. If you are not sure of the towns, list "any." You can also see who else is planning to attend, by clicking on "click here to see who is going to be there" at the bottom of the sign-in page. Even if you cannot attend this meeting due to conflicts in your schedule, please indicate the surnames and towns you are looking for in this area so that others at the meeting can contact you. I am also requesting that if you have records for surnames that others in the group are researching, please bring copies to share with them. We will be reviewing what indices still need to be digitized within these towns. Town Contacts attending, please bring reports about your towns for us to share. We may be starting a very big project soon which will be shared with you at the meeting. I look forward to seeing everyone again and meeting "new" Lodz Area Researchers who have not attended this group meeting before. All the best, Roni Roni Seibel Liebowitz IAJGS 2006 Conference Registration Chair and Exhibit Coordinator http://www.jgsny2006.org registration@jgsny2006.org Roni@jgsny2006.org Lodz ShtetLinks http://www.shtetlinks.jewishgen.org/Lodz/index.htm Lodz Area Research Group (LARG) http://www.shtetlinks.jewishgen.org/Lodz/LARG.htm Belchatow ShtetLink http://www.shtetlinks.jewishgen.org/belchatow/ Belchatow Shtetl CO-OP, Jewish Records Indexing- Poland, http://www.jri-Poland.org/belchatow.htm Belchatow Yizkor Book Project http://www.jewishgen.org/yizkor/Belchatow/Belchatow.html
|
|
Keith Hatfield <hatfield.1@...>
I am searcging for relatives of a Josef HOFFMAN born in Habry,
Czechoslovakia in 1860 to Alois Eljiezer and Therese Rivka. HOFFMAN. I believe that his son was Khaim Yekhil / Chaim HOFFMAN, who had recorded his details on the Yad Vashem site. Khaim Yekhil was I believe the husband of my Mother's Aunt Ida ADLER born in Lodz, Poland 14.1.1909. Does any one recognise these names? Regards Sherry Hatfield
|
|
Roni S. Liebowitz
The Lodz Area Research Group will hold its annual meeting at the Conference
on Tuesday at 3:15-4:30 in the Soho Room on the 7th floor of the Marriott Marquis Hotel. This is a group researching not only the city of Lodz, but approximately 80 surrounding towns. To see if this includes one of your towns in Poland, go to www.shtetlinks.jewishgen.org/Lodz/LARG.htm, click on towns, and scroll down for the list. If you are planning to join us, please sign-up at: http://www.shtetlinks.jewishgen.org/Lodz/signup.htm DO NOT enter your spouse's name if he/she is not attending or has no roots within these towns. List the surnames and towns you are researching ONLY >from this area. If you are not sure of the towns, list "any." You can also see who else is planning to attend, by clicking on "click here to see who is going to be there" at the bottom of the sign-in page. Even if you cannot attend this meeting due to conflicts in your schedule, please indicate the surnames and towns you are looking for in this area so that others at the meeting can contact you. I am also requesting that if you have records for surnames that others in the group are researching, please bring copies to share with them. We will be reviewing what indices still need to be digitized within these towns. Town Contacts attending, please bring reports about your towns for us to share. We may be starting a very big project soon which will be shared with you at the meeting. I look forward to seeing everyone again and meeting "new" Lodz Area Researchers who have not attended this group meeting before. All the best, Roni Roni Seibel Liebowitz IAJGS 2006 Conference Registration Chair and Exhibit Coordinator http://www.jgsny2006.org registration@jgsny2006.org Roni@jgsny2006.org Lodz ShtetLinks http://www.shtetlinks.jewishgen.org/Lodz/index.htm Lodz Area Research Group (LARG) http://www.shtetlinks.jewishgen.org/Lodz/LARG.htm Belchatow ShtetLink http://www.shtetlinks.jewishgen.org/belchatow/ Belchatow Shtetl CO-OP, Jewish Records Indexing- Poland, http://www.jri-Poland.org/belchatow.htm Belchatow Yizkor Book Project http://www.jewishgen.org/yizkor/Belchatow/Belchatow.html
|
|
Post WWI Austrian citizenship
#galicia
Suzan & Ron Wynne <srwynne@...>
This is in response to Lancy Spalter's provacative posting a couple of days
ago. I've been re-reading Wm. O. McCagg Jr.'s book The Story of Hapsburg Jews, 1670-1918 and, while McCagg doesn't specifically discuss the issue of post WWI citizenship, he does discuss the social and economic context of post-war conditions. The war had created tremendous physical disruption in Galicia. Galician Jews were expelled by the invading Russian army, whole towns along the path of battle were destroyed, and many Jews returned post-war, to find that they had to start all over again. Moving to Vienna, where about 200,000 very poor Galicians had lived in overcrowded and underemployed conditions pre-war, must have seemed a less attractive option than trying to stay in familiar surroundings where they had family and community support. I say Vienna, because, in Austria proper, few Jews lived outside of that city. Austria's punishment for the war was harsh. The country lost its territorial possessions and was reduced to a poor, mostly agricultural country with virtually no industry and very little economic power. Vienna had suffered badly in the 1873 economic downturn and never really recovered. Then, there was rampant anti-Jewish fervor in the rural and small town population outside of Vienna because the very conservative, Catholic populace was fearful of Socialism, which they associated with Jews. Altogether, not a very welcoming place. There were massive problems in Poland as well, of course. I don't mean to minimize them. But, it makes sense that people would have been seeking safety, a way to make a decent living, and comfort. It just doesn't seem that Vienna would have offered any of those features. I'd be interested in hearing >from others about their point of view on this topic. Suzan Wynne Kensington, MD
|
|
STEINHORN
#general
Michael D. Friedman, CEBS <FriedmanGenealogy@...>
I am searching for descendents of Avrahm STEINHORN. His sons Morris,
Benjamin and Joseph lived in an around Ellenville, NY and Greenfield Park, NY. All are buried in Ellenville. Morris once owned and operated the Grand Mountain Hotel and Camp in Greenfield Park. Please contact me directly at the address below. Thank you. Michael Friedman Michael@FriedmanGenealogy.com Researching: Friedman & Finkel (Grodno); Lechner (Gorodenka); Zimmer & Quicksilver (Chernovitz & Verachenka)
|
|
Gesher Galicia SIG #Galicia Post WWI Austrian citizenship
#galicia
Suzan & Ron Wynne <srwynne@...>
This is in response to Lancy Spalter's provacative posting a couple of days
ago. I've been re-reading Wm. O. McCagg Jr.'s book The Story of Hapsburg Jews, 1670-1918 and, while McCagg doesn't specifically discuss the issue of post WWI citizenship, he does discuss the social and economic context of post-war conditions. The war had created tremendous physical disruption in Galicia. Galician Jews were expelled by the invading Russian army, whole towns along the path of battle were destroyed, and many Jews returned post-war, to find that they had to start all over again. Moving to Vienna, where about 200,000 very poor Galicians had lived in overcrowded and underemployed conditions pre-war, must have seemed a less attractive option than trying to stay in familiar surroundings where they had family and community support. I say Vienna, because, in Austria proper, few Jews lived outside of that city. Austria's punishment for the war was harsh. The country lost its territorial possessions and was reduced to a poor, mostly agricultural country with virtually no industry and very little economic power. Vienna had suffered badly in the 1873 economic downturn and never really recovered. Then, there was rampant anti-Jewish fervor in the rural and small town population outside of Vienna because the very conservative, Catholic populace was fearful of Socialism, which they associated with Jews. Altogether, not a very welcoming place. There were massive problems in Poland as well, of course. I don't mean to minimize them. But, it makes sense that people would have been seeking safety, a way to make a decent living, and comfort. It just doesn't seem that Vienna would have offered any of those features. I'd be interested in hearing >from others about their point of view on this topic. Suzan Wynne Kensington, MD
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen STEINHORN
#general
Michael D. Friedman, CEBS <FriedmanGenealogy@...>
I am searching for descendents of Avrahm STEINHORN. His sons Morris,
Benjamin and Joseph lived in an around Ellenville, NY and Greenfield Park, NY. All are buried in Ellenville. Morris once owned and operated the Grand Mountain Hotel and Camp in Greenfield Park. Please contact me directly at the address below. Thank you. Michael Friedman Michael@FriedmanGenealogy.com Researching: Friedman & Finkel (Grodno); Lechner (Gorodenka); Zimmer & Quicksilver (Chernovitz & Verachenka)
|
|
Re: Citizenship after WWI
#galicia
Bev Beiman <bbevy@...>
Fellow researcher M. Goldberger drew my attention to the relevant clauses ofThe truth is, I don't know the answer why, but I can add something to the mystery. My Galician family spent WWone in Vienna. After the war they spent their time waiting for one of my uncles to return >from a Russian POW camp and tending various members of the family back in Bucaczowce who were caught up (and died) in the Spanish Flu epidemic. The family moved to The Netherlands in 1920. At the archives in The Hague I found passport applications, before they became citizens of Holland, for my grandfather and several of my older uncles dated in the 20s. They were not granted passports but rather Laissez Passers as "stateless persons", noting that the country they came from, namely the Austrian Empire, no longer existed and they therefore had no citizenship at all. I don't have the documents at hand for the exact wording, but that is the gist of it. Beverly Shulster Yehud, Israel
|
|
Ressler-Raskin
#general
Michael D. Friedman, CEBS <FriedmanGenealogy@...>
I am searching for descendents of Abraham Ressler, including Gertrude
"Gussie" Glassman Ressler Friedman. Abraham was my ggrandmother's brother. She died in Europe. He is buried in Mt. Zion Cemetery in Maspeth, Queens, New York. Please contact me at the address below. Thank you! Michael Friedman Michael@FriedmanGenealogy.com Researching: Friedman & Finkel (Grodno); Lechner (Gorodenka); Zimmer & Quicksilver (Chernovitz & Verachenka)
|
|
Gesher Galicia SIG #Galicia Re: Citizenship after WWI
#galicia
Bev Beiman <bbevy@...>
Fellow researcher M. Goldberger drew my attention to the relevant clauses ofThe truth is, I don't know the answer why, but I can add something to the mystery. My Galician family spent WWone in Vienna. After the war they spent their time waiting for one of my uncles to return >from a Russian POW camp and tending various members of the family back in Bucaczowce who were caught up (and died) in the Spanish Flu epidemic. The family moved to The Netherlands in 1920. At the archives in The Hague I found passport applications, before they became citizens of Holland, for my grandfather and several of my older uncles dated in the 20s. They were not granted passports but rather Laissez Passers as "stateless persons", noting that the country they came from, namely the Austrian Empire, no longer existed and they therefore had no citizenship at all. I don't have the documents at hand for the exact wording, but that is the gist of it. Beverly Shulster Yehud, Israel
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen Ressler-Raskin
#general
Michael D. Friedman, CEBS <FriedmanGenealogy@...>
I am searching for descendents of Abraham Ressler, including Gertrude
"Gussie" Glassman Ressler Friedman. Abraham was my ggrandmother's brother. She died in Europe. He is buried in Mt. Zion Cemetery in Maspeth, Queens, New York. Please contact me at the address below. Thank you! Michael Friedman Michael@FriedmanGenealogy.com Researching: Friedman & Finkel (Grodno); Lechner (Gorodenka); Zimmer & Quicksilver (Chernovitz & Verachenka)
|
|
Re: Citizenship after WWI
#galicia
Brian J. Lenius <brian@...>
I don't usually (maybe never before) wade in on a debate without very
concrete information, but I find this question rather interesting. The answer, once discovered, can provide all researchers with a small piece of history to add to their family histories. Lancy Spalter: Fellow researcher M. Goldberger drew my attention to the relevant clausesof the Treaty of Peace between the Allied and Associate Powers and Austria.The answer is that Galitzianers were automatically granted Polish citizenshipof them did.Thanks to Lancy Spalter for this thought provoking and relevant question and to M. Goldberger for the subsequent info re: "Treaty of Peace" clauses. Is it possible that there might be other clauses in this treaty that might spell out conditions to opt for Austiran citizenship? The answer to Lancy's question should be of interest, not only all Jewish Galicianers but, to those of all other ethnic groups in Galicia as well. It is also a question where maybe looking at other ethnic groups might provide some insight for Jewish researchers. While mulling this over in my mind, it seems that one point would be obvious. Those who were ethnic Poles would not wish to become Austrian citizens for one obvious reason - the new country was created effectively for them. As for all the rest, Ukrainian, Jewish, and German (to name the major ones) - it seems the same decision (or "none decision" really) was made. It is always easier to "not" make a decision (i.e. "do nothing") and so that might have been part of it. While Lancy's third possibility might have been true (I don't know), it seems that perhaps one of the first 2 possibilities or maybe even a 4th could have been the main reason - something more universal. The vast majority of not only Ukrainians, but also those of German ethnicity, did not become Austrian citizens. This I can personally state this with fair certainty. It is perhaps most striking that almost all German "colonists" also did not take up this offer. They had such a strong tie to being "Austrian" partially due in part to their German culture and language and also due in part to their gratitude to the Austrian Monarchy for the invitation and opportunity to settle there in the first place (late 1700's & early 1800's). In fact, if one looks at the Canadian 1911 census, it seems that Ukrainians >from Galicia most often identified themselves as "Galician", but the German immigrants >from Galicia most often identified themslves as "Austrian. So to me this is what makes the question even more intriguing. Maybe a fourth universal possibility might be that there were conditions applied to that citizenship that most Galicians regardless of ethnicity (other than ethnic Poles), did not find attractive. For example, maybe Austrian citizenship required relocating to the "new" Austrian soil. This would not be attractive to most residents in Galicia, because it would mean leaving relatives, friends, land, businesses, and more behind. Also, land and opportunities in the much smaller, and now economically recovering, Austria might not be as attractive. This requirement might also make sense politically as one would be hard-pressed to see how citizens of one country (new Austrian citizens) would be allowed to remain resident in another country (the "new" Poland) especially when the former had just recently been enemies with the later. One can think of all kinds of potential problems, such as the potential for the new "Austrian" citizens to form some sort of insurgency. That is but one of many scenarios that one could conjure up. I do apologize for the long message especially since it is not filled with known facts, but I am hoping that it might be a bit thought provoking. I too am interested in discovering the answer to Lancy's second question and hope others will weigh in. Again, maybe the answer lies in further clauses of the "Treaty of Peace". Regards, Brian J. Lenius Selkirk, MB, Canada
|
|
Street Name Helps...
#general
Joel Weintraub <jweintraub@...>
On digest yesterday an inquiry was made about an "Attebury" street in
Trenton NJ found on the US Census for 1910. The person was trying to locate the street. One way of checking streets is to use our geographical search aids at the Morse One Step site at http://www.stevemorse.org/ Using the website, going to the 1910-1940 Census utility, choosing 1910, then New Jersey, and then choosing Trenton, an alphabetical list of all streets that we compiled from either the census, NARA descriptions of census districts, or othersources are shown. We quickly see that there is an Atterbury Avenue in Trenton. A modern map shows the street still exists. If a modern map did not show the street, then our utility on Street Name Changes on the One Step site might help in finding the current name of the street. At the NY conference this August I'm giving a computer workshop on how these geographical databases were arrived at. I'm interested in showing people who have used the geographical utilities the assumptions that they are working with when they use the databases, and the search assumptions of the One Step search engine in terms of how that influences results. Joel Weintraub Dana Point, CA
|
|
Gesher Galicia SIG #Galicia Re: Citizenship after WWI
#galicia
Brian J. Lenius <brian@...>
I don't usually (maybe never before) wade in on a debate without very
concrete information, but I find this question rather interesting. The answer, once discovered, can provide all researchers with a small piece of history to add to their family histories. Lancy Spalter: Fellow researcher M. Goldberger drew my attention to the relevant clausesof the Treaty of Peace between the Allied and Associate Powers and Austria.The answer is that Galitzianers were automatically granted Polish citizenshipof them did.Thanks to Lancy Spalter for this thought provoking and relevant question and to M. Goldberger for the subsequent info re: "Treaty of Peace" clauses. Is it possible that there might be other clauses in this treaty that might spell out conditions to opt for Austiran citizenship? The answer to Lancy's question should be of interest, not only all Jewish Galicianers but, to those of all other ethnic groups in Galicia as well. It is also a question where maybe looking at other ethnic groups might provide some insight for Jewish researchers. While mulling this over in my mind, it seems that one point would be obvious. Those who were ethnic Poles would not wish to become Austrian citizens for one obvious reason - the new country was created effectively for them. As for all the rest, Ukrainian, Jewish, and German (to name the major ones) - it seems the same decision (or "none decision" really) was made. It is always easier to "not" make a decision (i.e. "do nothing") and so that might have been part of it. While Lancy's third possibility might have been true (I don't know), it seems that perhaps one of the first 2 possibilities or maybe even a 4th could have been the main reason - something more universal. The vast majority of not only Ukrainians, but also those of German ethnicity, did not become Austrian citizens. This I can personally state this with fair certainty. It is perhaps most striking that almost all German "colonists" also did not take up this offer. They had such a strong tie to being "Austrian" partially due in part to their German culture and language and also due in part to their gratitude to the Austrian Monarchy for the invitation and opportunity to settle there in the first place (late 1700's & early 1800's). In fact, if one looks at the Canadian 1911 census, it seems that Ukrainians >from Galicia most often identified themselves as "Galician", but the German immigrants >from Galicia most often identified themslves as "Austrian. So to me this is what makes the question even more intriguing. Maybe a fourth universal possibility might be that there were conditions applied to that citizenship that most Galicians regardless of ethnicity (other than ethnic Poles), did not find attractive. For example, maybe Austrian citizenship required relocating to the "new" Austrian soil. This would not be attractive to most residents in Galicia, because it would mean leaving relatives, friends, land, businesses, and more behind. Also, land and opportunities in the much smaller, and now economically recovering, Austria might not be as attractive. This requirement might also make sense politically as one would be hard-pressed to see how citizens of one country (new Austrian citizens) would be allowed to remain resident in another country (the "new" Poland) especially when the former had just recently been enemies with the later. One can think of all kinds of potential problems, such as the potential for the new "Austrian" citizens to form some sort of insurgency. That is but one of many scenarios that one could conjure up. I do apologize for the long message especially since it is not filled with known facts, but I am hoping that it might be a bit thought provoking. I too am interested in discovering the answer to Lancy's second question and hope others will weigh in. Again, maybe the answer lies in further clauses of the "Treaty of Peace". Regards, Brian J. Lenius Selkirk, MB, Canada
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen Street Name Helps...
#general
Joel Weintraub <jweintraub@...>
On digest yesterday an inquiry was made about an "Attebury" street in
Trenton NJ found on the US Census for 1910. The person was trying to locate the street. One way of checking streets is to use our geographical search aids at the Morse One Step site at http://www.stevemorse.org/ Using the website, going to the 1910-1940 Census utility, choosing 1910, then New Jersey, and then choosing Trenton, an alphabetical list of all streets that we compiled from either the census, NARA descriptions of census districts, or othersources are shown. We quickly see that there is an Atterbury Avenue in Trenton. A modern map shows the street still exists. If a modern map did not show the street, then our utility on Street Name Changes on the One Step site might help in finding the current name of the street. At the NY conference this August I'm giving a computer workshop on how these geographical databases were arrived at. I'm interested in showing people who have used the geographical utilities the assumptions that they are working with when they use the databases, and the search assumptions of the One Step search engine in terms of how that influences results. Joel Weintraub Dana Point, CA
|
|
Re: NYT article on 21st Street Cemetery in NYC
#general
Teri Tillman <natzrose@...>
In regards to the article in yesterday's New York Times about Congregation
Shearith Israel's 21st Street Cemetery, I would be very interested in obtaining a paper copy of this article for my files. If a JewishGenner in NYC who subscribes to the NYT would be willing to send me his / her copy of this article, please contact me privately. Thank you. Teri Tillman Natchez, Mississippi
|
|
JewishGen Discussion Group #JewishGen Re: NYT article on 21st Street Cemetery in NYC
#general
Teri Tillman <natzrose@...>
In regards to the article in yesterday's New York Times about Congregation
Shearith Israel's 21st Street Cemetery, I would be very interested in obtaining a paper copy of this article for my files. If a JewishGenner in NYC who subscribes to the NYT would be willing to send me his / her copy of this article, please contact me privately. Thank you. Teri Tillman Natchez, Mississippi
|
|