JewishGen.org Discussion Group FAQs
What is the JewishGen.org Discussion Group?
The JewishGen.org Discussion Group unites thousands of Jewish genealogical researchers worldwide as they research their family history, search for relatives, and share information, ideas, methods, tips, techniques, and resources. The JewishGen.org Discussion Group makes it easy, quick, and fun, to connect with others around the world.
Is it Secure?
Yes. JewishGen is using a state of the art platform with the most contemporary security standards. JewishGen will never share member information with third parties.
How is the New JewishGen.org Discussion Group better than the old one?
Our old Discussion List platform was woefully antiquated. Among its many challenges: it was not secure, it required messages to be sent in Plain Text, did not support accented characters or languages other than English, could not display links or images, and had archives that were not mobile-friendly.
This new platform that JewishGen is using is a scalable, and sustainable solution, and allows us to engage with JewishGen members throughout the world. It offers a simple and intuitive interface for both members and moderators, more powerful tools, and more secure archives (which are easily accessible on mobile devices, and which also block out personal email addresses to the public).
I am a JewishGen member, why do I have to create a separate account for the Discussion Group?
As we continue to modernize our platform, we are trying to ensure that everything meets contemporary security standards. In the future, we plan hope to have one single sign-in page.
I like how the current lists work. Will I still be able to send/receive emails of posts (and/or digests)?
Yes. In terms of functionality, the group will operate the same for people who like to participate with email. People can still send a message to an email address (in this case, main@groups.JewishGen.org), and receive a daily digest of postings, or individual emails. In addition, Members can also receive a daily summary of topics, and then choose which topics they would like to read about it. However, in addition to email, there is the additional functionality of being able to read/post messages utilizing our online forum (https://groups.jewishgen.org).
Does this new system require plain-text?
Can I post images, accented characters, different colors/font sizes, non-latin characters?
Can I categorize a message? For example, if my message is related to Polish, or Ukraine research, can I indicate as such?
Yes! Our new platform allows members to use “Hashtags.” Messages can then be sorted, and searched, based upon how they are categorized. Another advantage is that members can “mute” any conversations they are not interested in, by simply indicating they are not interested in a particular “hashtag.”
Will all posts be archived?
Can I still search though old messages?
Yes. All the messages are accessible and searchable going back to 1998.
What if I have questions or need assistance using the new Group?
Send your questions to: support@JewishGen.org
How do I access the Group’s webpage?
Follow this link: https://groups.jewishgen.org/g/main
So just to be sure - this new group will allow us to post from our mobile phones, includes images, accented characters, and non-latin characters, and does not require plain text?
Will there be any ads or annoying pop-ups?
Will the current guidelines change?
Yes. While posts will be moderated to ensure civility, and that there is nothing posted that is inappropriate (or completely unrelated to genealogy), we will be trying to create an online community of people who regulate themselves, much as they do (very successfully) on Jewish Genealogy Portal on Facebook.
What are the new guidelines?
There are just a few simple rules & guidelines to follow, which you can read here:https://groups.jewishgen.org/g/main/guidelines
Thank you in advance for contributing to this amazing online community!
If you have any questions, or suggestions, please email support@JewishGen.org.
The JewishGen.org Team
My great grandmother was Rabbi Nathan Israel Brenner’s sister. We believe he was born in 1861 around Pakruojus, Lithuania. His grandson was David Brenner (the comedian). His father was Shloma Zalman Brenner and his mother was Ruchal; step mother was Sphrintz Bernstein. Rabbi Brenner immigrated to US early 1890s. They are buried at Har Nebo cemetery, outside Philadelphia. We recently put a Brenner Research group together on Facebook - I will post your inquiry there to see if anyone has knowledge of his writings. I was told he was absolutely incredible with his knowledge on Torah and Jewish law.
Dan Preissman <preissman@...>
Include the upper right hand notation, I will like the following document translated . It is on ViewMate at the following address
akaran1@... or do it on ViewMate.
Re: Sharing family tree information #general
Judy Russell does not say it is ok to take other's research and post as your own without credit. Here is just one example: legalgenealogist.com/2017/09/27/don't-just-take/
which I have quoted part of below.
While it is true that facts are not can not be copyrighted - such as date of death, etc.- it is true that as Judy says, "Taking someone else’s work and using it ourselves — even if it’s not for commercial gain — isn’t sharing.
And it’s wrong.
It violates every ethics code our community has:
• The National Genealogical Society’s Guidelines for Sharing Information with Others notes that “responsible family historians consistently— identify the sources for all ideas, information and data from others, and the form in which they were received, recognizing that the unattributed use of another’s intellectual work is plagiarism.4
• The Code of Conduct of the International Association of Jewish Genealogical Societies provides that “If data presented relies on work already previously undertaken, proper credit for such work should be given to the originator…”5
• The code of ethics of the Board for Certification of Genealogists requires Board-certified genealogists to pledge that: “I will not represent as my own the work of another. … In citing another’s work, I will give proper credit.”6
• The code of ethics of the Association of Professional Genealogists requires members to promise to “Give proper credit to the work of others and refrain from plagiarism.”7Why would anyone want to write a nonfiction book if their time/perspective/ input left their research and conception of events open to plagiarism?
I am glad you brought this up so we could discuss it.
Carolyn Lea (Schwarzbaum)
Please help and translate this whole document including the writing in the upper right hand corner
I've posted the vital record in German. . It is on ViewMate at the following address ...
Please respond via the form provided on the ViewMate image page or email me at akaran1@....Thank you very much
I've posted a vital record in Russian for which I need a translation. It is on ViewMate at the following address ...
Please respond via the form provided on the ViewMate image page.
Thank you very much.
Thank you very much for searching the register books and providing translations to the information listed therein. I had not realized that there were 2 sets of books and that the books contain separate entries. I quite probably would have overlooked the entry for the death of Karline. I had realized that she had died prior to the 1842 Census in Bovenden, as shown in Die judischen Einwohner Bovenden Tom 17. bis 19. Jahrhundret, a part of which I have typed in below.
Name Vorname geb.Mon./Jahr 1839 1842 1845
Meyersburg Gerson 11.1815 x x x
Ehefrau Julie 9.1816 x x
Samoel 5.1840 x x
Chanette 5.1844 x
This census information shows that Julie was the name of Gerson's wife as of 1842. Schewelchen is not mentioned. Also that Samuel was acknowledged as a Meyersburg.
A paragraph from Geschichte der judischen Gemeide Bovenden lists Samuel Meyersburg by name at age 18, which further indicates that he was considered legitimate.
I have several more entries from that register which I will be putting into ViewMate for translating in the next weeks.
Again my sincere thanks,
Re: Jewish Argentinians #latinamerica
Alberto Guido Chester
Shelley Mitchell has posted a surprising statement (transcribed below) with which I strongly disagree.
There are many studies both academic and non academic which can illustrate readers on the (small) magnitude of Jewish prostitution in 1930's Argentina in relation to the (huge) magnitude of Jewish migration into Argentina.
But generalizing dates as she does (1870 to WWII) and places of origin (see quote) and minimizing the enormous number of Jews who made a new decent life in this country is an oversimplification.
She ignores the important books and papers on the subject by saying "it must be studied and understood".
If Ms. Mitchell can provide bibliography to prove her points I'd be more than willing to read them.
I do feel sorry for the women engaged in prostitution in the 1930's by Jewish pimps and the profusely studied Zvi Migdal delictive ring, but her post is doing a disservice by a crude generalization.
Hope this helps to clarify the matter.
"One point in history not frequently discussed was the enslavement of Jewish immigrants from 1870 to WWII. They were forced into prostitution, mostly in Argentina. And many of their “owners” were Jewish. It is for that reason alone, many of these unwilling women will be lost to researchers. It’s doubtful that they were buried where their names would be known. Plus many arrived alone from Germany, Austria, and Western Europe. It’s an embarrassing aspect of our history but it must be studied and understood"
Alberto Guido Chester
Buenos Aires, Argentina
Re: Ukraine Brick Wall MILLSTEIN #ukraine
I had a neighbor growing up in Philadelphia named Dr. David Milstein. He lived and practiced on Christian Street in the 5800 block, at the corner of 59th Street. My family always said he was a landsman, that his people came from the same town In Ukraine as ours did — Krasnoye, Podolia Gubernia, Russia ( Now Ukraine). Happy hunting,
Molly Arost Staub
Bova Raton, Fl
Re: : HIAS & Ethnic Bank records in Philadelphia, PA #belarus
my great great grandmother, I believe was from Pakruojus, Lithuania her name was Minnie (Sphrintz) Bernstein (1850s - 1921) She married Solomon Brenner (1840s - 1905). They lived in Philadelphia ( immigrated around 1885) and are buried at Har Nebo, Philadelphia. We have been trying to chase her side without results and mixed results on the Brenner side prior to Solomon. Around 1895 Solomon purchased a ticket for Chana Bernstein (perhaps niece) from Pakruojus to Philly when Chana was 19 years old (Rosenbaum bank passage records). She probably married and we are unable to find trace of her other than passenger ticket. Their child, Rabbi Nathan Israel Brenner was the grandfather of David Brenner (comedian). They had several other children including my great grandmother Olga Brenner (Kasdin).
Re: Abbreviation OT in US Census #usa
I asked this question of 5/18:
Does anyone know what the abbreviation “OT” next to a name in the 1910 US census signifies? See, for example, the entry for Harriett HARRIS in the cropped attachment Harris.jpg. I am guessing that it means “Out of Town,” because that would explain why she is also listed with her husband and oldest child as Hattie SCHULTE in the second attachment, but it is only a guess. Both censuses show her as married four years with one living child, although her listed ages differ by one year.
It appears that it is a notation for who spoke to the census taker and stands for "other". That is to say, not the heard of the family or the spouse. Most of them read "Wf" for wife.
Ralph N. Baer RalphNBaer@... Washington, DC
Re: Percentages of ancestry - my Ashkenazi father seems to be partly of Italian/Greek descent? #dna
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
(I tried to use the links at the bottom to reply, but it opens
some email window that I am unfamiliar with.)
To everyone, please add dates to ggggrandparents, such as gggrandparent(b.1890),
otherwise there is no time reference for us to look at. Your gggrandparnet could
be my father's classmate.
Now to an answer. The DNA data does not give an absolute location but
a statistical probability location. When speaking of southeast Europe/N. Africa
and the Middle East, at the time between 1500-1900 the area was
mostly controlled by the Ottomans, and I expect many people,
especially military and political, traveled. Mistresses and one-night-stands are
not things invented in the last few years, but Thomas Jefferson and
DDE (to name just 2 POTUSs) were both well known to have mistresses.
When you start to read readin,
how do you know the fellow that
wrote the readin,
wrote the readin right?
Long Branch Saloon
Dodge City, Kansas
On Saturday, May 23, 2020, 05:53:45 PM GMT+3, <swerner@...> wrote:
I had my genes tested by FamilyTreeDNA. I already knew I had two very different lines of ancestry. My father's Ashkenazi Jewish (Belarus, Ukraine). My mother's of Irish and German descent. My results came back: Ashkenazi 38%, Ireland/British Isles 27%, West and Central Europe 23%, Southeast Europe 9%, East Europe < 3%.
The Southeast European bit was sort of a surprise. On my mother's side I know back to my great-great-great-grandparents in all cases and further back than that in some cases. (Of course, this assumes that everyone's father was the person their mother was married to.) On my father's side I only know back to my great-grandparents plus, in three out of four cases, their parents as well.
Is it possible that some of my father's ancestors came from Southeast Europe and later immigrated to the Pale to escape persecution? It's rather tantalizing that 38% + 9% + 3% adds up to 100%. (Of course, it could also be that some of that 23% West and Central Europe is coming from my father's side as well as my mother's. For example, my mother's Irish ancestry arises from three different women who immigrated from Ireland independently of each other, at different times and possibly from quite different parts of Ireland.)
I should also note that both my parents are now deceased. Each of them had one sibling, also now deceased. My father's sister had no children. So asking him or her or them to get their DNA tested isn't possible.
Many thanks for any info!
RABINOVICH: Chopovichi, Ukraine
GITELMAN: David-Gorodok, Belarus
Re: How do I get a copy of the death record of Zelman BERKOWITZ who died in Odessa on 16 Dec 1924 #ukraine
Family and DNA
Just an aside -- are we sure that this grave is in Odessa? Who is
in the picture? What does the grave say?
My dad's grandmother (Zelman's daughter Leike/Elisabeth) always said she was "from Odessa." But on her 1911 ship manifest she says she was born in "Chersonska", her last residence was Lokhvitsa, Poltava (she's also listed as living there in 1908 on her husband Israel Amberg's ship manifest, & he seems to have been from there) -- & her dad "Salmon Berkowitz in Chersonska" is listed as her contact back home in 1911. So I'm assuming the Berkowitzes were there for a while before coming to the US. https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:JJL3-9YD
When I was first in contact with you, I was just starting my
family tree research. I've got to go back in & correct so many
things -- and continue also to credit you in the places where you
gave me the info! So many loose ends...
I never did go & look for ship manifests for all the other Berkowitz folks who went to Buffalo, I need to do that! I was able to see Tzipa's 1918 Buffalo death index info, but I don't have her death certificate, gravestone, or anything else really.
Why did she come to the US without her husband -- or did he come also & then go back to Russia/Ukraine, & then die there in 1924?
I've been helping download all the new Ukraine records being posted online by Alex Krakovsky on Wikipedia, I've totally lost track of my own research & my family tree is crap. There are Kherson records up now there, so we may have some leads, but I can do spreadsheets etc, but cannot read Russian or Hebrew...
Best regards from France,
On 5/24/2020 18:32, LarryBassist@... wrote:
/// Russia: BENIN / BERLAND Czernigow; Romny, Poltava > (Paris>) Chicago AMBERG BERKOWITZ EPSTEINE Odessa, Kherson, Poltava > (Paris >) Buffalo NY; Chicago GELBURD / GAYLBURD / GOLDBERG / GILBERT Vinnitsya; Nemyriv; Priluki Staraya; Podolia gub. > Philadelphia; Atlantic City; Milwaukee /// Galicia/Poland: BADER Felsztyn (Skelivka) > Philadelphia BADIAN Komarno? FELDMA(N)N Wolanka / Boryslaw > Philadelphia FREIDENHEIM Stryj, Drohobycz, etc. GERTLER Komarno, Wolanka, Stryj, Drohobycz, etc. WEINER/WIENER ? /// Germany: ADELSDORFER ? BÄR / BAER Buttenhausen > mid-W US, esp. near Vandenburgh Co, IN. EPSTEI(N)N Willmarsch?, Röhrenfurth/Melsungen, Sachsenhausen, Guxhagen > Luxembourg; Amsterdam; mid-W US, esp. near Vandenburgh Co, IN HAUSSMAN Heidenheim? ISAAK Fellheim? MEYER Hannover > Aurora, IN. MOSES Gottenheim/Gottersheim, Sachsenhausen, Röhrenfurth. ROSENSTEIN Stuttgart; Elberfeld? > Philadelphia, Lancaster, PA.
Another factor is that Polish does have German influences since Poland-Lithuania rules Prussia for 250 years. As a result Rabinovitz was in Polish Rabinowicz, pronounced as Rabinovich.
GenTeam Recht.als.Unrecht - Property registrations in Vienna from 1938 to 1945 #austria-czech
Jan Meisels Allen
This is from Prof. Ing. Felix Gundacker, Vienna from GenTeam.eu:
The website is: www.GenTeam.eu
Initial checks of the archival fonds of the "Vermögensverkehrsstelle" (Assets Transfer Office) which were handed over to the Austrian Archives of the Republic in 1989 revealed that the holdings and the name index were often not consistent. This quickly led to the idea of setting up an electronic database which would allow researchers to quickly gain access to the required archival material.
It was only through this database established in many years of arduous work that genealogical research on the victims of the holocaust as well as scientific research by international historians were made possible.
"Recht als Unrecht" initiated an intensified debate on confiscations and restitution. In 1998 and 2003, official Austria reacted with the foundation of the National Fund for the Victims of National Socialism and a mandate to the Historical Commission.
On behalf of the entire research community I would like to sincerely thank Hofrat Dr. Hubert Steiner for creating this database and making it available to GenTeam.
Additional databases on Jewish genealogy and restitution:
Besides this highly valuable new database, GenTeam offers additional important resources for genealogy and restitution, such as a complete index of the Israelitische Kultusgemeinde (IKG) of Vienna (as well as data from Jewish communities in Lower Austria, Burgenland and Moravia), Jewish resignations 1868-1945, IKG divorces, converts, proselytes, foundling baptisms, the Jewish cemeteries of Vienna, Eisenstadt and Innsbruck as well as Nuremberg, civil marriages from Vienna, Graz and Salzburg, the Jewish familiants of Prague as well as an index for "Wer einmal war", volumes 1 and 2. Further references to Jewish families can be found in the databases of newspaper obituaries, the Vienna index of baptisms and the database on Jewish gravestones.
Jan Meisels Allen
Chairperson, IAJGS Public Records Access Monitoring Committee
Illegitimate births circa 1906 #galicia
I am researching an illegitimate birth in the Stanislawow region of Galicia in 1906. The story in the family was that the mother was later sent to America because of the shame, but the child was a loved and accepted part of the family. I'm wondering if anyone out there has any research or documentation (memoirs/Yizkor books) that deal with this issue in Galicia.
Sharon Taylor Philadelphia, PA stay9045@...
NEMETH, KASTENBAUM, WEISNER, FLEISIG in Stanislawow and L'viv regions of Galicia FISHER, RAPPAPORT in Lithuania
you are looking for consistency in transliteration between at least 3 different alphabets, and 5 or more different languages?toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
-ovich, regardless of spelling, is a slavic suffix meaning "son of". it's used, as far as i know, in russian, ukranian, polish, slovak, most of the balkans, and even romania, in either latin or cyrillic alphabets. from there, it goes to yiddish, in hebrew letters, and then transliterated into latin letters using either german or english spelling conventions. and then sometimes into modern hebrew. (i don't know if any slavic version ends in the "tz" sound of the hebrew tzadi.) i can't imagine that there's a single, consistent and rational way to do this. there isn't even consistency in the original languages, because polish, german, hungarian and romanian, just for example, all write the "ch" sound differently, and some aren't even consistent within themselves. (e.g. hungarian spellings vary between "-ovits" and "-ovics", even for the same individual. both are valid and pronounced the same.)
you can either accept the (historic) inconsistency, or attempt to impose your own idea of what is correct. my experience is that i prefer to be more consistent in my own records, just because it wastes time to not have members of the same family grouped together, and to have to remember to check alternative spellings all the time. but i suppose that from a purely academic research point of view, i should really record all the variant spellings exactly as i find them.
....... tom klein, toronto <tomk@...>
At 13:27 -0700 23/5/20, main@... wrote:
Does anyone know a linguistic reason to prefer a transliteration of
Seeking Joseph Weisman, a member of Proskurover in NYC #ukraine
When your message includes the name of a place that's not familiar to everyone (Proskurov) please include the country.
The JewishGen Gazetteer says Ukraine for this one. - Moderator
Searching for any information about Joseph Weisman. He was a member of Proskurover in NYC. My family is also Weisman from Proskurov but settled in Chicago in 1912. My mggf Mendel had at least 2 brothers, Akiva and another who we lost touch with. Thanks for your help.
Meryl Harris Goldberg <firstname.lastname@example.org>
Seeking the NEUMANN family group /landsmnaschaff in either lower east side or the Bronx, NYC #usa
Any way to find family club /landsmanshaft?
My father remembers his grandmother going to meetings somewhere in ny either lower east side or the Bronx. My gg grandmothers maiden name was Hanna Neumann (or some variation phonetically Newman ) married isadore Weiss and lives in the Bronx and Newark nj.
Shimon Rosenberg <grubness@...>
Signing your full name to your messages furthers the spirit of community and mutual assistance that our group depends on.
Researching YELLIN > LEVIN family from Wysockie Maz, Jablonka, Zambrow > USA #poland
Moderator note: If your message mentions towns or regions that aren't well known places, please add the country to the local name.
Does any of this ring a bell? If so, would be interested in hearing from you.
I have quite a bit of information on this branch of YELLINs.
My ggf was Azariel Zelig (Zelk) YELLIN. His father’s name was Srol (1807-77) and
his mother’s name was Rochel Leah. Srol’s His grandfather’s name was Hersh.
According to the marriage records of two of Zelig’s daughters, he was married to
Marim Rochle KRZEWICZ. I now have their marriage record as well. They were
married in June 1877. Her parents were Boruch and Dwejra.
According to Srol Yellin’s death record from 1877, these are their children:
Sons: Joszk Jankiel , Zelik, Pejsach Herszk and Matys
Daughters: Sora Jenta and Bejla Itka
My grandfather, Sam Levin, was born Sam Yellin in Wysockie Maz, probably around
1890. He settled in Chicago and in 1913, married ANNA BEDO(WICZ) who was from
Zambrow. They had three children, Ida (z”l), Sol (z"l), and my father Jack
(z”l), all who lived in Chicago, although Ida moved to California and passed
away there in 2017 at 102. My grandfather was the youngest in the family.
According the one of the last folks from the old country, my grandfather had six
sisters and one brother – Sarah (Surki), Chana, Pesha Mindile (Bessie), Molkie
(Malcha), Shelub,and Bella Itka, and Lazar. I believe only the first three and
my grandfather got out of the old country. I have the marriage record of Bella
(Itka) Yellin. She married Chilko (Hillel) Slklo (son of Shi and Pesia
(Bessie)), also of Wysockie Maz, in Wysockie on November 28, 1909. She was
26, he was 25. They were married by Rabbi Aron Perlman, the last rabbi of
Wysockie. He perished in the Holocaust, as I assume this couple did. Based on
one of the other records I have, Bessie Yellin was born in 1880. Surki married
Abe Zaitz in Wysockie in 1895. Bessie married to Harry Slodki in Wysockie in
1900. (These two couples settled in Chicago before the war). Malcha married
Chilko Blodsztejn in Wysockie in 1907). I have this marriage record as well.
They did not leave the old country.
Chana married a COHEN. They had five children, Lil, Ann, Sylvia, George, and
Freda. Ann married a ROSENBERG. They had at least one child, Bert, who
married Joan in New York in 1957. I understand this branch of the family
lives(d) in Bell Harbor, New York.
Bessie married Harry SLOTKY (Slodki) in Wysockie in 1900. They had four
children, Joe, Meyer, Sol, and Sam. They lived in Chicago.
Somewhere along the line, there is a Nathan (Nissan) Yellin. I have been in
contact with his descendents. Nissan (SONA in Yiddish) YELLIN had six or seven
kids, including Velvel Wolf YALEN who married Fanny PEARLMAN and Schmule YELEN.
These two children settled in the Hartford area. Sona also had a daughter,
Rebecca YELLIN who married Lazer BEN r. NEHEMIAH. They eventually settled in
Columbus, Georgia. My grandfather frequently visited with this branch of the
family including cousins Mildred (Feinberg) Green and Bernice (Feinberg)
Weinstein. There were so many cousins, that I understand there was a "Sona's
Club," which was an annual gathering of cousins somewhere in the southeast
during the 1930s. Sona also had a son BEROL who was born around 1859. He
married Asna Leah BERENSZTEJN in Lomza or Jablonka in 1880. According to the
marriage record, Sona was married to Basia, daughter of BEREK, and that Sona’s
father’s name was Lazar (Lejzor). One of their children, Bessie, married Sam
Zaitz who was from Wysockie. The story is that he changed his name to Yellin
when my grandfather brought him over from the old country. The cousin
relationship may be here because Abe ZAITZ married my great aunt Sara (Surkie)
YELLIN in Wysockie Maz in 1895. This couple had five children: Julius, Zelda
(Sylvia), Joe, Sol, and Sam (who took back the name Sam YELLIN).
Sandy Levin <s.levin@...>
List the surnames/towns that you are researching in the JewishGen Family Finder.
How do I get a copy of the death record of Zelman BERKOWITZ who died in Odessa on 16 Dec 1924 #ukraine
List the surnames/towns that you are researching in the JewishGen Family Finder.